Michelin Pilot Sport 4S is the best warm-weather street tire anybody's ever made and not by a little. By a lot. Don't drive it in snow ever. The similarities in scores between these two tires is misleading because those are really two very different tires. The cross climate is a great all-weather Tire. But on either a dry or a wet Road above 45 degrees, it would have its clock cleaned by the 4S. If you need a tire that can handle occasional light snow duty, take a look at the Pilot Sport All Season 3 +. It's the best handling and Performing Tire with some functionality in snow and winter conditions.
