Austin, question, have you been around Tesla stuff long enough to remember when there was no X and the S owners were complaining that they wished the fob was smaller, thinner? Their shouts were for a smart card. Something they could carry in the wallet. And another group at the time wanted to simply use their smartphone - passing on the smart card hoping the phone only method would happen sooner if they didn't ask for the smart card. After a while the complaining faded into the background and we heard no more about a smart card from these folks.
Now jump ahead three+ years and the 3 folks got only smartphone and smart card connectivity. And they have learned its not fun to use. And they wish they had the fob that the S folks didn't want. I personally am glad the 3 folks are getting the fob and the option of getting the fob if they want it. Those that are not unhappy can continue to use the smart card.
So what's my point? I think its simply ironic that those S owners that wanted a smart card are very quiet now harvesting the dislike from the 3 folks that really don't like not having the fob. Sometimes we just don't know how good we have it until someone reminds us we are well off, huh?