The main difference is also cost... for the Pilot Sport AS/4, 255/45-20 is actually the cheapest at $272... The 265/40-20 is $431. The OEM 255/40-20 is in between at $350.Mmmmm BEEFY!!
I love that look. Can you post more pictures of your car. Any pros or cons to running this tire? I want the AS4's.. and trying to figure out which size to get. Stock 255/40.. or 255/45 for extra comfort.. or 265/40 for extra wheel protection & comfort. Seems the only drawback to going bigger.. is small hits to efficiency and speedometer.
In terms of speedo, going by my DWS-06 Plus, in 255/45-20, I was expecting my speedo to be more off, but I found it to be more accurate than stock... With the OEM 255/40-20 Goodyears, when my speedo said 80, I was actually going 77. With my 255/45-20 Contis, when my speedo says 79 I'm actually going 80. At lower speeds, when my speedo said 60, I was actually going 60. (These were verified with GPS and Radar). YMMV.