Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register
  • We just completed a significant update, but we still have some fixes and adjustments to make, so please bear with us for the time being. Cheers!

Traveling by Supercharger can be more expensive than ICE

Nickage87

Member
Nov 28, 2019
112
33
USA
Bikes don't do so well in the snow and ice. They also don't allow taking equipment to and from work.
Hm..
F983179E-D458-451D-A19B-EA2A5C6FA51A.jpeg
 
  • Funny
Reactions: SSonnentag

mk677

Member
Feb 10, 2021
127
57
jacksonville fl
I thought Tesla said they wouldn’t make the superchargers a profit center? After paying $14.56 for driving 140 miles from home charger to Supercharger and topping off, I realized it would have been cheaper to drive my pickup. At the current cost of fuel which is $2.25 per gallon here this equates to an ICE getting 21.5mpg. Not too impressive. A regular car comparable to a Model 3 would easily get 30mpg, probably more like 35-40mpg.

Are the supercharger rates here in Montana just excessively high, or is that the normal across the nation.
Makes me really miss free supercharging....
as someone with grandfathered free supercharging I can't address the cost of charging, where supercharging got very expensive for me is when my wife joins me on a trip and I stop for a charge she hits the stores and buys all sorts of stuff. her shopping is far more costly than filling a car with fuel every few hours.
 

Gasaraki

Active Member
Oct 21, 2019
1,374
939
Syracuse, NY
The issue really is that 1) gas is so cheap, 2) the rates at superchargers depend on what state you are in and the regulation. In some states they can't charge you by the amount of energy you used...
 
  • Helpful
Reactions: lUtriaNt

Gasaraki

Active Member
Oct 21, 2019
1,374
939
Syracuse, NY
Which, in Tesla’s case, is significantly less expensive than paying by the kWh.

Because they are taking the lost cause they know that paying by the minute in a case where charging is slow is a big ripoff. You should see how much Electrify America and EVgo charge people. It's highway robbery.

I can say that Tesla is not trying to make money from the Supercharger Network. In Norway, they are actually trying to charge people $0.09/KWh at certain times to entice people to charge at off peak hours. This will probably come to the US if it is successful.
 
Last edited:

house9

Supporting Member
Nov 16, 2019
329
352
California
In Norway, they are actually trying to charge people $0.09/KWh at certain times to entice people to charge at off peak hours. This will probably come to the US if it is successful.

They have done this in parts of California off and on, I think last time was during Thanksgiving holiday.
 

Big Earl

bnkwupt
Jul 12, 2017
4,915
8,790
Springfield, VA
I can say that Tesla is not trying to make money from the Supercharger Network. In Norway, they are actually trying to charge people $0.09/KWh at certain times to entice people to charge at off peak hours. This will probably come to the US if it is successful.

Tesla is already implementing time of use rates at some locations here in the US. My local supercharger is one of those locations, at $0.18 off peak and somewhere in the $0.30s peak. I’ve seen similar in California and a few other states.

Lately, the average national price seems to be around $0.28/kWh (anecdotal observation from my own experiences).
 

LoudMusic

Member
Jul 21, 2020
263
328
Arkansas
Tesla is already implementing time of use rates at some locations here in the US. My local supercharger is one of those locations, at $0.18 off peak and somewhere in the $0.30s peak. I’ve seen similar in California and a few other states.

Lately, the average national price seems to be around $0.28/kWh (anecdotal observation from my own experiences).

I've just had a scroll through my Supercharging history. The most I've paid was $0.30/kWh in DC. The least was $0.14/kWh in Springfield, VA. That was 50kWh at 10:30AM last year. Typically seems like low to mid $0.20s.

In the states where they charge by the minute I'm showing Tier 1 as low as $0.11/min, for just a handful of minutes ... And Tier 2 upwards of $0.25/min.
 

drdumont

Member
Nov 22, 2019
257
244
North Texas
Was just perusing my charges. Discovered recently that every S/C session from Day 1 was available, even the original freebies.

A recent session at Lindale...
Power Tier 1 16 min @ $0.11/min $1.76
Power Tier 2 15 min @ $0.22/min $3.30
Tax included
$0.39

So what is the difference in the Tiers? (Yes, I know, one is twice the price of the other...). When does Tier 2 kick in?
 

SSonnentag

Rocket Scientist
Apr 11, 2017
1,709
2,161
Arizona
Was just perusing my charges. Discovered recently that every S/C session from Day 1 was available, even the original freebies.

A recent session at Lindale...
Power Tier 1 16 min @ $0.11/min $1.76
Power Tier 2 15 min @ $0.22/min $3.30
Tax included
$0.39

So what is the difference in the Tiers? (Yes, I know, one is twice the price of the other...). When does Tier 2 kick in?

I'm pretty sure the crossover point is 60 kW.
 

LoudMusic

Member
Jul 21, 2020
263
328
Arkansas
I'm pretty sure the crossover point is 60 kW.

Correct!

Supercharging

It's to "hopefully" make it more fair for the time/cost based on kWh delivered during that period. They could get more specific but there's also the issue of overcomplicating it.

$/min is used when the state requires a company to be a utility provider in order to sell by $/kWh. I believe Kansas and Tennessee are two examples? Arkansas used to be but now allows Tesla (and others) to sell by kWh. I literally JUST read this in our AR EV group on Facebook.

152022410_10107177510917792_8993968704886395224_n.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: HelixSpiral

drdumont

Member
Nov 22, 2019
257
244
North Texas
SSonnentag said:
I'm pretty sure the crossover point is 60 kW.

Loudmusic concurs.

/ Scheming Cheap Old Man Mode enabled

I've noticed I get a separate bill each time I plug in.
Recently I unplugged and moved to another spout after a few minutes, as it was really s l o o o w. Got a bill for $0.90, then a bill for the rest of the charge...
Ergo, looks like I could consume <60KW, unplug, then
plug in and restart the clock at the lower rate? Might have to move to another spout. Hmmm...
<rubs hands together>
Time for some testing and firkytootling!
-- After all this white crap goes away.

/ Scheming Cheap Old Man Mode disabled
 
  • Funny
Reactions: KenC and AdamMacDon

SageBrush

REJECT Fascism
May 7, 2015
12,084
14,993
New Mexico
/ Scheming Cheap Old Man Mode enabled
/ Scheming Cheap Old Man Mode disabled
Tesla automagically puts the charges in their correct charging speed buckets

NM used to be per minute. It changed in 2020
Back then Supercharging was almost as cheap as home charging via the grid

I'm looking forward to my PV (finally!!) getting installed this spring. Then 90% of my EV charging will cost ~ 0.2 cents a mile
You read that right
 

LoudMusic

Member
Jul 21, 2020
263
328
Arkansas
SSonnentag said:
I'm pretty sure the crossover point is 60 kW.

Loudmusic concurs.

/ Scheming Cheap Old Man Mode enabled

I've noticed I get a separate bill each time I plug in.
Recently I unplugged and moved to another spout after a few minutes, as it was really s l o o o w. Got a bill for $0.90, then a bill for the rest of the charge...
Ergo, looks like I could consume <60KW, unplug, then
plug in and restart the clock at the lower rate? Might have to move to another spout. Hmmm...
<rubs hands together>
Time for some testing and firkytootling!
-- After all this white crap goes away.

/ Scheming Cheap Old Man Mode disabled

It's kW not kWh. That's speed of charge, not capacity. The charge speed is based on the state of charge of the car's battery. If charging by the minute, you have to sit longer as the charge rate slows down. This is why they reduce the price per minute when the charge rate falls below 60kW.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big Earl

smartypnz

Supporting Member
Jan 23, 2013
1,954
2,101
Monterey Peninsula
We're still at just over 100k gas stations..... with several pumps each

But 10,000,000,000,000,000+ electrical outlets in the US.

Edit: Actual number is just over 30 trillion electrical outlets in the U.S.
 
Last edited:
  • Funny
Reactions: drdumont and KenC

drdumont

Member
Nov 22, 2019
257
244
North Texas
It's kW not kWh. That's speed of charge, not capacity. The charge speed is based on the state of charge of the car's battery. If charging by the minute, you have to sit longer as the charge rate slows down. This is why they reduce the price per minute when the charge rate falls below 60kW.

Duhhh. That's embarrassing. I knew that.

Note to self: No posting after 3 Margaritas and a shooter.
 

one2many

Member
Aug 16, 2019
553
739
germany
Note to self: No posting after 3 Margaritas and a shooter.

Whats the fun of that.

OK at $6.50 per gallon here, Just savings on gas ($5K a year) I payed off
my 10kwp solar system in two years. On top of that I get $1K for the extra juice I
generate. I can afford $15 in supper duper charging. Yep I know I am comparing
Jack to coke but there better together. At 15kwp I break even for all my juice.
 

About Us

Formed in 2006, Tesla Motors Club (TMC) was the first independent online Tesla community. Today it remains the largest and most dynamic community of Tesla enthusiasts. Learn more.

Do you value your experience at TMC? Consider becoming a Supporting Member of Tesla Motors Club. As a thank you for your contribution, you'll get nearly no ads in the Community and Groups sections. Additional perks are available depending on the level of contribution. Please visit the Account Upgrades page for more details.


SUPPORT TMC
Top