I’m not new to modding...been modding my cars for the past 21yrs...from wheels/tires, suspension, full exhausts to engine/trans swaps, diffs etc.. I focus on balance between track and daily street ability...and always followed the old adage that it’s best to stay with the original overall diameter. Otherwise you can run into issues with suspension/fender clearance, speedometer accuracy and potential negative handling impacts. Best/correct way to deal with fender gap is by suspension. If you’re not happy with the drop with the Eibachs why not get a different spring or better yet coilover setup that you can tweak to the exact height that you’re looking for?
original tire size is 235/35/20. If you’re running 235/30/20, that’s a smaller diameter and could make the fender gap look even bigger. Maybe that’s your issue? If you’re going to go wider 245/35/20 is the best choice and closest to OE diameter. But IMO the Tesla spec ps4s 235/35/20 runs wide and is just about as wide as the 245 version. Tesla acoustic ps4s 235/35/20 has tread width of 8.8” And 245/35/20 has a tread width of 8.7”.