I received my Model Y LR in September and love it. My wife wants to go electric with our second car. Should I go Tesla model Y again knowing what I am getting, or should I consider some of the newer offerings such as the Kia EV6, Hyundai Iqonic 5 or the Mustang Mach E (benefits include the tax credit and some variety). I am sure others have had this dilemma.
-
Want to remove ads? Register an account and login to see fewer ads, and become a Supporting Member to remove almost all ads.
Two Model Y Family
- Thread starter AgentWD40
- Start date
Tam
Well-Known Member
Because of the advantage of discount, I would be willing to get the second EV as a non-Tesla.
The first one (Tesla) would be for fun and long road trips.
The second one (non-Tesla) would be for local trips and tax credits.
lawmangr
Member
I think it really comes down to use case. As much as I love Tesla and feel they are best for pretty much everyone, I'm capable of an objective analysis and have researched the competitors (all of the ones you mentioned and more). I think it comes down to your goals. Some key questions are: What do you like best about your Model Y? What do you dislike? How far do you drive on a daily basis? How often would you road trip with the car?
MY1stEV
Member
I'm excited to see all the EVs coming from other manufacturers, but I don't have enough confidence in any them yet to give them my money.
gx9901
Member
As much as I love my MYP, I don’t think I would ever want two of the same car in my household if it was my decision, simply because I’d like some variety. My wife feels the same way and when she wanted to get in EV we decided on a Volvo C40. We just picked it up this week and I think it’s a great car for her. I’ve really enjoyed driving it so far as well. Definitely a good compliment to my MYP in our garage.
Personally I never understood spending tens of thousands of dollars on something else just because you want some variety. If my wife’s car was also my ideal car, then that is what I would also get. Couldn’t imagine getting something “lesser” for the sake of variety, but that is assuming it meets fewer of your needs.
I would narrow it down to one or two other vehicles and compare them to the Y. If you don’t find anything that is is a deal breaker then maybe some variety is a good thing.
Just make sure you look at those things that Tesla owners take for granted too. Supercharger network, software updates, fast infotainment system, etc. I hear people overlook that and realize afterwards it was a mistake.
I would narrow it down to one or two other vehicles and compare them to the Y. If you don’t find anything that is is a deal breaker then maybe some variety is a good thing.
Just make sure you look at those things that Tesla owners take for granted too. Supercharger network, software updates, fast infotainment system, etc. I hear people overlook that and realize afterwards it was a mistake.
Two Model 3 household, here. It’s working out well.
Midnightsun
Active Member
Went through the same thing, pre-ordered and Ionic 5. Cancelled order after some time and bought myself a 22 model S LR. Could not be happier.
Decided against the Ionic mainly because we are talking to different environments when it comes to operation and the biggest factor was charging compatibility and range. My Wall connector at home and at the office would not have worked. The simplicity of plug and play at Superchargers would have been a no go. Over 10 years of building EVs must have given tesla an upper hand. Would not have ordered another Y, not because it is not a great car, just want something different to choose from depending on when and where we are going. The refreshed Model S is just way too cool to disregard, love it.
Decided against the Ionic mainly because we are talking to different environments when it comes to operation and the biggest factor was charging compatibility and range. My Wall connector at home and at the office would not have worked. The simplicity of plug and play at Superchargers would have been a no go. Over 10 years of building EVs must have given tesla an upper hand. Would not have ordered another Y, not because it is not a great car, just want something different to choose from depending on when and where we are going. The refreshed Model S is just way too cool to disregard, love it.
As an owner of 2 Tesla vehicles (M3LR & MYLR owner) I'll say go for another brand.
Tesla has proven reliability (all my Tesla's had minor fit & finishes issues but that's about it), but recent price increases means you're spending >$60k for a new MYLR. For ~$50k, the Ioniq 5 & EV6 are total winners, and this is not factoring the $7500 federal tax rebate.
Ioniq 5 + EV6 = more features (i.e. Carplay, 360 camera), quieter ride, more comfortable ride, longer warranty
Mach E = while less efficient, also more features and a quieter ride & 2nd year of the model
Have your wife sit & test drive each of these, if possible. But I personally believe the MY is overrated, especially for the current price.
Personally, I'll be selling/trading the MY with my eye on the EV6...if you can wait long enough, Toyota/Subaru/Lexus are coming out with their EV's later this year plus for ~$60k, the Cadillac Lyriq can also be had.
Tesla has proven reliability (all my Tesla's had minor fit & finishes issues but that's about it), but recent price increases means you're spending >$60k for a new MYLR. For ~$50k, the Ioniq 5 & EV6 are total winners, and this is not factoring the $7500 federal tax rebate.
Ioniq 5 + EV6 = more features (i.e. Carplay, 360 camera), quieter ride, more comfortable ride, longer warranty
Mach E = while less efficient, also more features and a quieter ride & 2nd year of the model
Have your wife sit & test drive each of these, if possible. But I personally believe the MY is overrated, especially for the current price.
Personally, I'll be selling/trading the MY with my eye on the EV6...if you can wait long enough, Toyota/Subaru/Lexus are coming out with their EV's later this year plus for ~$60k, the Cadillac Lyriq can also be had.
all others have yet to proven reliability and yet to be tested. EVs come down to 3 factors: battery, charging station & software-and nobody else is close to that yet. I made a mistake thinking that I need 2 different EVs-my 2017 Bolt battery recall or fix is taking way too long-still not dome after 17 months since a got the first snail mail from GM. While my MY is getting better, never older with OTA updates. I shouldn't have sold my 2018 M3 to buy the Bolt. Don't make decision on tax credit incentive and childish taste.
mackgriggs
Member
I've shown this before here. Just get a different color and you'll be fine. If the model Y is the best current choice for both of you, then absolutely get 2. I'm still waiting on a truck (I have 8 different reservations for all of the different brands, though cybertruck is still at the top of my list), and my wife is still thinking about a r1s, but for now, model y is the best for us. Our good family friends also bought their first model y about 2 months ago, and on Tuesday are picking up their second MYLR and trading in their escalade for the exact same reason. I originally told him that after getting a Tesla 2 years ago, that "I won't go back to a gas car", and he thought I was exaggerating until he got one and they fought over who could drive it. He is definitely a believer now.
Zer0Her0
Member
Forget the cars, I'm more interested in the house! Nicely done.
RoBoRaT
PoPeYeD'SaiLoRDuDe
2020 MYP + 2021 7 Seater MY LR here.
We considered others but the delaer upcharge above MSRP is crazy nowadays - negates Tax Credits (if you have that much tax liability to begin with).
Waiting in 2022 MYP to replace the 2020 MYP since resale values are
now.
We considered others but the delaer upcharge above MSRP is crazy nowadays - negates Tax Credits (if you have that much tax liability to begin with).
Waiting in 2022 MYP to replace the 2020 MYP since resale values are
now.That's vaporware at this point, like lots of promising ev companies. Until they can be produced in volume these are not comparable.
digitaldad
Member
RoBoRaT
PoPeYeD'SaiLoRDuDe
Good looking cars!
Your white Y looks like one from this one YouTuber.
An aside, what brand are your front ground fx and fog light brows?
