Thanks! I wrote a detailed review on the whole process which I posted on reddit. Here's the link if anyone is interested:
Buying a CPO (used) Model S 85D experience : teslamotors
To answer your question specifically, it met my threshold of what I was willing to accept but there were a couple of small damages I could not see in the photos. As most of you probably know, the photos you get with the CPO process is hit or miss. I passed up a few great deals based on the low quality photos. This one I ended up purchasing had pretty good photos, 1600x1200 resolution and no photos that indicated any damage. Some of the things I noticed when I took delivery:
- Three rock chips and some pitting on the windshield. Two of them were repaired (filled) but one of them is not repaired. I took it to Safelite and they told me they could try to repair the last chip (biggest one), but there's a chance the entire window could crack, so I left it alone.
- A few small (~0.5 in) but deep scratches (well beyond the clear coat and paint) on the rear bumper. It's only slightly visible when the hatch is closed.
- Several small rock chips throughout the car (front bumper, hood, b-pillar, mirrors, etc.).
- Front bumper lip scraped on the bottom/side.
- Some light scuffs (all fixed when I did a full detail).
- One small pen mark on the driver seat.
I'm waiting to hear back from the delivery agent I was working with to see if there's anything Tesla can do about the windshield and rear bumper. I understand these used vehicles will have some wear and tear (i.e. small rock chips), but the rock chips on the windshield seem a bit excessive, especially considering one of them is likely not repairable, and the rear bumper scratches are not what I would define as normal wear and tear. Additionally, both of these were not disclosed in the photos which I was told any damage(s) would be.
Edit: Here's a link to some photos I took to show the damages I'm talking about -
Dropbox - 2015 Tesla Model S 85D - Simplify your life