Valet Parker Wrecks $450,000 Ferrari After Mistaking Accelerator for Brake

[notAmeenPerson]

Parking Attendant Totals Ferrari in Rome After Pressing Wrong Pedal

So, do you trust Tesla Valet mode?

 

[AnOutsider]

That's one heck of a mistake. Not sure what it has to do with trusting Tesla's valet mode though. It won't stop mistakes from happening, but if they do happen, it may lessen the intensity of a situation like this since it reduces power. Again though, I'd more ask how it affects your trust in valets in general.

 

[AudubonB]

Why would I trust something that limits speed to 70mph/110kph? Valet mode should limit speed to 15mph/20kph.

I can see an "Offspring mode", or an "In-laws Mode", or something equally snarky, for which 70mph might be fine. But TM has let me down with that 70mph limit.

 

[yobigd20]

valet-mode should park itself with no attendant necessary.

 

[Ugliest1]

Why would I trust something that limits speed to 70mph/110kph? Valet mode should limit speed to 15mph/20kph.

Totally agree. And limit acceleration to 20 kW.

 

[mibaro2]

If this incident had happened to a Tesla, we would be hearing how the brake pedal and accelerator are too close together, etc.
I agree valet mode should be reduced to a much lower speed.

 

[dsm363]

If this incident had happened to a Tesla, we would be hearing how the brake pedal and accelerator are too close together, etc.
I agree valet mode should be reduced to a much lower speed.

Yes. We should have David Nolan write an article about that.

 

[RDoc]

Well, once the anti-collision system is in place (Real Soon Now), presumably the car would have stopped itself.

 

[Saghost]

Parking Attendant Totals Ferrari in Rome After Pressing Wrong Pedal

So, do you trust Tesla Valet mode?

If you believe the interpretation the article put on it, the valet mostly got into trouble because there was so much power/torque available. A Valet mode that limited acceleration to 60 kW (or 20 like another post suggested) would quite effectively prevent that sort of problem. Collision avoidance braking might also help...

 

[TTT]

I can see why Tesla limited the speed to only 70mph, so that if they pick up the car they can drive at freeway speeds. I personally wouldn't set valet mode if Tesla picked my car up. This is a good reason to have the speed limit adjustable in valet mode. Maybe even have multiple settings as are available for driver profiles. I would then create a few profiles, Valet-Tesla, Valet-Parking, and Family Test Drive

 

[eco5280]

I have never and will never use a valet. I would rather park 1/4 mile away and walk then let someone sit in and drive my car. I don't even want service techs touching it but that's inevitable :biggrin:

 

[ItsNotAboutTheMoney]

Why would I trust something that limits speed to 70mph/110kph? Valet mode should limit speed to 15mph/20kph.

I can see an "Offspring mode", or an "In-laws Mode", or something equally snarky, for which 70mph might be fine. But TM has let me down with that 70mph limit.

Sometimes, valet parking means driving your car on city streets over to a lot somewhere.
- Really need three modes: private lot valet, city street valet, I do not trust my friend/relative valet