Mardak's link in post #517 led me to a video of a test-drive on the then-latest beta version. It was indeed impressive. The driver says in the information under the video that the system does indeed require hands-on-the-wheel, and that the driver is responsible for taking over. It's not the car's job to alert the driver, though the car may do so. In that video she does disengage several times rather than test whether the car would hit someone. She is very careful and responsible.
Conclusion: It is amazing what it can do! But it's still far from ready to be Level 3 or 4. And the streets in her neighborhood are upscale-looking, wide and well-maintained. Nothing at all like the streets where I live.
I could not tell from the video if she had to confirm green lights, or if the car drives through them without driver input. I think I read a while back, with reference to the wide-release version, that the driver has to give the okay before the car will drive through a green light, as an additional safety measure.
She comments on an issue I have with EAP: "FSD" will operate no faster than 5 mph over the speed limit. When traffic is heavy and moving faster than that, your choices are to hold back traffic, or disengage AP and drive manually. This is an issue in places where the speed limit is significantly lower than the road conditions would allow for safety, and lack of enforcement means that everybody drives ten to fifteen or more over the limit.
Conclusion: It is amazing what it can do! But it's still far from ready to be Level 3 or 4. And the streets in her neighborhood are upscale-looking, wide and well-maintained. Nothing at all like the streets where I live.
I could not tell from the video if she had to confirm green lights, or if the car drives through them without driver input. I think I read a while back, with reference to the wide-release version, that the driver has to give the okay before the car will drive through a green light, as an additional safety measure.
She comments on an issue I have with EAP: "FSD" will operate no faster than 5 mph over the speed limit. When traffic is heavy and moving faster than that, your choices are to hold back traffic, or disengage AP and drive manually. This is an issue in places where the speed limit is significantly lower than the road conditions would allow for safety, and lack of enforcement means that everybody drives ten to fifteen or more over the limit.