Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register
  • The final cut of the 9th episode of the Tesla Motors Club Podcast, featuring Chad Schwitters, the former president of Plug In America, is now available. You can watch it now on YouTube or listen to it on all major podcast networks.

Will Tesla Semi decelerate quicker than ICE semis?

Rate of deceleration would be a consideration for accident avoidance, then you talk about long decent and overheating friction brakes that is a very different thing even though the end result can be an accident.

Tire/brake rate of decel would suggest basically a panic stop situation, tires are usually the limiting factor, Traditional semi also have compression release braking they can use, so while it is not capturing energy like regen does it is a supplemental way of slowing the vehicle without the friction brakes if the location can allow the noise.

You ever stop to think that maybe the regen system could get overheated by the same prolonged grades that can overheat a regular semi's brakes? In which case hopefully the friction brakes are still cool enough to do the work in which case it would be those evil old archaic failure prone friction brakes that save us from the limits of regen.

I trust the semi regen system will be well engineered and reduce friction brake wear but it is still going to have limits like everything else, what those limits are we don't know, in all reality inside Tesla they are probably still working that all out.
 

mongo

Well-Known Member
May 3, 2017
14,526
49,100
Michigan
Given that holding speed on a downhill takes less energy than maintaining speed on the uphill, I do not forsee the regen system overheating. Of course, that will depend on how it is implemented.
Hopefully, the operators get sufficient training (or software buffer) to not fully charge the battery when at the the highest elevation on the trip.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MP3Mike

WannabeOwner

Well-Known Member
Nov 2, 2015
6,692
3,471
Suffolk, UK
Hopefully, the operators get sufficient training (or software buffer) to not fully charge the battery when at the the highest elevation on the trip

I wondered that too, however how much capacity is needed to store Regen from a long / steep descent?

If charged to, say, 90% would the 10% remaining be enough for "Regen on any, realistic, hill"?
 
  • Like
Reactions: lklundin

mongo

Well-Known Member
May 3, 2017
14,526
49,100
Michigan
I wondered that too, however how much capacity is needed to store Regen from a long / steep descent?

If charged to, say, 90% would the 10% remaining be enough for "Regen on any, realistic, hill"?

Might not, semi may use 1.6kWh/mile. That is equal to the potential energy of 80k pounds moved 53 feet vertically (basically it can go forever on a 1% slope). At a 2% slope, it gains 1.6kWh per mile. 3,300 feel of elevation is 100kWh or 60ish miles. Very route dependent.

Then, depending on pack set up, regen may or may not be limited at 90%.
 

iwannam3

Active Member
Aug 8, 2016
1,025
1,412
Washington
Cabbage or Deadman Hill on I-84 eastbound in Oregon is 7 miles long and drops over 3,000 feet at 6% and has truck speed limits based on weight. Also has 2 runaway truck ramps!
75,000+ = 18 mph!
70,000 = 22mph
65,000 = 26mph
50,000 = 37 mph
Could regen alone keep an 80,000 truck at 18 mph? Will regen be adjustable? I wonder how fast it could go uphill? Can regen absorb the same power that the motors can deliver on the uphill segment? Can you charge and discharge a battery at the same rate or is one limited?
 
Cabbage or Deadman Hill on I-84 eastbound in Oregon is 7 miles long and drops over 3,000 feet at 6% and has truck speed limits based on weight. Also has 2 runaway truck ramps!
75,000+ = 18 mph!
70,000 = 22mph
65,000 = 26mph
50,000 = 37 mph
Could regen alone keep an 80,000 truck at 18 mph? Will regen be adjustable? I wonder how fast it could go uphill? Can regen absorb the same power that the motors can deliver on the uphill segment? Can you charge and discharge a battery at the same rate or is one limited?
Going by experience in a Model X:

* Dunno, maybe. But probably not.
* On S and X, it is adjustable, but most people leave it on regular, instead of weak.
* No. I can deliver about 320kW, but only absorb about 75kW.

I doubt regen getting limited because of too much downhill grade will ever be a problem. You basically have to start with a 100% charge at the top of a mountain to do it. I’ve done it, once, with exactly that. I started in Duck Creek Village, UT at 100%, expended about 5% climbing out of town, had full regen, and then 30 minutes later regen started to get a bit limited as I approached 97% charge, driving 40mph the whole way downhill (no brakes until regen was limited) to Cedar City, UT. I’ll let the enterprising reader look up the distance and altitude change. But in normal driving, a semi will never charge to 100% during a long drive, and definitely not at the very top of a huge long hill. And if it does happen, it’s just a minor annoyance.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Brando

WannabeOwner

Well-Known Member
Nov 2, 2015
6,692
3,471
Suffolk, UK
I’ll let the enterprising reader look up the distance and altitude change.

EV Trip Planner says :)

Net Elevation Change -2670 feet
Journey 30 miles
Total Energy Used 4.1 kWh / 13 RM
Average Efficiency 136 Wh/mile

A Better Route Planner (doesn't show elevation change) agrees on 30 miles and 136 Wh/mile

definitely not at the very top of a huge long hill

... but naive / newbie / idiot might ... :(

if it does happen, it’s just a minor annoyance.

Brakes would get hot on a semi with no regen?
 

mongo

Well-Known Member
May 3, 2017
14,526
49,100
Michigan
Could regen alone keep an 80,000 truck at 18 mph? Will regen be adjustable? I wonder how fast it could go uphill?

Elon said it will do 60MPH up a 5% grade. That's around 1.6 kW for moving and 477 kW to climb. If semi pack is 800kWh, that is 8x a normal pack with 2x the drive units. If normal regen limit is 75kW, say it can do 200kW of regen.

Heading downhill, 200kW is 1.85 feet per second decent rate (ignoring aero/rolling for the moment). 60MPH is 88fps, so if the grade is 7%, the truck speed would be 18 MPH.
For a 6% grade at 18MPH, regen would be 172kW.

Rolling resistance would be a third of the 60MPH number and aero 1/9. So that adds in about 350W of buffer (non factor).

Handy calculator, setting output to kJ and height to feet, while inputting feet per second climb/ descent rate, gives KW output (J=W×s).

Brakes would get hot on a semi with no regen?

Very, if the truck lost regen, it would need to stop. All the energy from the above calculation goes staright into heat (spread across 10 brake units). Normal trucks use engine braking for the bulk of speed control.
 

Big Earl

bnkwupt
Supporting Member
Jul 12, 2017
6,856
13,443
Springfield, VA
Most modern diesel semis can provide between 300 and 450 horsepower (225 - 335 kW) worth of engine braking power. That's in addition to the stopping power provided by the friction brakes. I expect the Tesla to be able to match that or provide more regenerative braking, depending on what the battery packs can handle.

If we assume that regeneration is limited to 50% of the battery's maximum charging power, we get something close to 500 kW of regenerative braking. Model S and X both regenerate at a maximum of 60 kW, which is half of their maximum charge speed of 120 kW. I think the Model 3 is similar.
 
Last edited:
You ever stop to think that maybe the regen system could get overheated by the same prolonged grades that can overheat a regular semi's brakes? In which case hopefully the friction brakes are still cool enough to do the work in which case it would be those evil old archaic failure prone friction brakes that save us from the limits of regen.
oh right. Generators burn up all the time from overuse.
That is why Nuclear reactors melt down, right?
I guess wind generators don't burn up cause of the wind cooling effect. Maybe we should put windmills on trucks to help stopping?

OK, tell the truth, you write for the Onion. Coffee out my nose and now I'm crying. I just love your comment.
great, really funny.

thanks.
 
oh right. Generators burn up all the time from overuse.
That is why Nuclear reactors melt down, right?
I guess wind generators don't burn up cause of the wind cooling effect. Maybe we should put windmills on trucks to help stopping?

OK, tell the truth, you write for the Onion. Coffee out my nose and now I'm crying. I just love your comment.
great, really funny.

thanks.
No need for sarcasm. Not everyone here has the same level of technical knowledge.
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: UncaNed and Brando

Silent Ludicrosy

Member
Supporting Member
Mar 14, 2018
946
12,876
Phoenix
9257C518-8111-45DD-8C0F-F110A46D76C4.jpeg
 
  • Informative
Reactions: Kacey Green
oh right. Generators burn up all the time from overuse.
That is why Nuclear reactors melt down, right?
I guess wind generators don't burn up cause of the wind cooling effect. Maybe we should put windmills on trucks to help stopping?

OK, tell the truth, you write for the Onion. Coffee out my nose and now I'm crying. I just love your comment.
great, really funny.

thanks.

Although the generator might not overheat, the battery getting hot or filling up is a real concern. Although I suppose with the rumored 1MW charging rate it’d take quite a bit to overwhelm that battery!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kacey Green
OK, mountains have been covered, but if the OP is talking single stop I still say yes.
Most trucks still use drum brakes because they are lighter and cheaper than discs. The Tesla semi will have discs and superior anti skid braking. That should translate to shorter stops than most semi's.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: neroden
Most modern diesel semis can provide between 300 and 450 horsepower (225 - 335 kW) worth of engine braking power. That's in addition to the stopping power provided by the friction brakes. I expect the Tesla to be able to match that or provide more regenerative braking, depending on what the battery packs can handle.

If we assume that regeneration is limited to 50% of the battery's maximum charging power, we get something close to 500 kW of regenerative braking. Model S and X both regenerate at a maximum of 60 kW, which is half of their maximum charge speed of 120 kW. I think the Model 3 is similar.

The battery packs handling it isn't a concern. You see, there will be a giant Tesla brand Tesla Coil to handle the discharge of excess energy preferably generating music.
 

Products we're discussing on TMC...

About Us

Formed in 2006, Tesla Motors Club (TMC) was the first independent online Tesla community. Today it remains the largest and most dynamic community of Tesla enthusiasts. Learn more.

Do you value your experience at TMC? Consider becoming a Supporting Member of Tesla Motors Club. As a thank you for your contribution, you'll get nearly no ads in the Community and Groups sections. Additional perks are available depending on the level of contribution. Please visit the Account Upgrades page for more details.


SUPPORT TMC
Top