I think they finally got it right. Tesla Model S: The 2013 Yahoo! Autos Car of the Year | Motoramic - Yahoo! Autos
We have been talking about that here: http://www.teslamotorsclub.com/showthread.php/10824-2012-2013-Awards
I thought the article wasn't that flattering of the S considering the award that was being bestowed on the car: The manner in how they reported these isolated issues implied to this reader the S is not ready for prime time and struck me as more FUD. The article left me uncertain about the car, certainly not a car worthy of the distinction of Car of the Year.
Lots of ignorant people in the world (or lots of trolls from other car companies commenting it down).