Oh I'm fully on board with your 1Q treading water theory. Glad I moved the last of my BPS to May yesterday!
I just think we're rapidly moving out of the pandemic and this inflation will reverse quite rapidly.
There's a lotta money out there and 4Q tech earnings were real strong. I could see guidance at 1Q earnings getting a boost across the sector. We shall see!
It's going to be an interesting dynamic for sure. On one side, you have inflation care bears and just bears in general that have been waiting years for a "I told you so moment". On the other side, you have actual earnings that, just like every earnings season for the past few years, just crushed it. You have to ask.....what happens by around Q1's earnings and then Q2's earnings.....when companies are continuing to post earnings growth that's not impacted by inflation.
I'll add something and I'm sure some here will probably take a bit of issue with it, but I honestly do not think 7.5% YoY inflation matters to the economy. Now obviously if in a year inflation is up 7.5% YoY again, well then that's another story.
But inflation was stagnate for a long time. As pointed out here before, housing has gone up quite a bit in a number of areas, but that's primarily due to the migration of the tech workforce and remote workers. The people that were already living in those areas aren't paying a higher mortage. And the people that are on the move, are actually saving money on their housing/renting because they're moving from much higher cost of living areas. Food prices are higher but people are still actually saving money because again, remote work has taken over. Instead of spending money eating out for breakfast, lunch, dinner, they're buying groceries. So even if grocery prices are higher, people are still overall paying less on food. As for gas, now consumers actually have options for EV's that completely negate the increases in oil/gas. And not only does an EV negate any inflation in gas, overall deflates the cost of the car over time.
Now there will be a group/part of the economy that does get hit by this inflation and will see their discretionary spending contract a bit. Mainly because they won't enjoy the offset of remote working that I mentioned above because well, they weren't being hit by those things to begin with. And this will probably be the most controversial part of this post, but as we saw during the first year of Covid......this group doesn't matter to real GDP output,. the health of the economy, and most importantly to earnings for companies. They simply don't contribute enough to it to matter.
Thus I'm fairly confident that for the first half of this year and Q1 and Q2's earnings, we're going to see continued stellar earnings/revenue growth while at the same time getting lousy "old school" GDP tracking metrics. And that will result in a lot of dumbfounded looks by traditional economists and wall st bears that though this 7.5% inflation tick signals a major incoming recession and that the stock market is overvalued.
I expect a lot of "How are these companies doing this well when inflation has taken away all of the discretionary spending of the consumer????" The answer will be, it hasn't taken away discretionary spending due to deflation that's not showing up in traditional inflation/deflation metrics.
But it's going to take time for all that to really show, which is why I'm not that optimistic for Q1. I think Q1 and Q2 will be mostly flat quarters for the market overall.....and that's a good thing actually.