Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register

Which Chinese Auto Maker...?

evme

Member
Jul 5, 2013
615
2
NY
Why does it need to be an auto maker? It possibly could be just a manufacturer partner (ie, Foxconn).

Foxconn is not Chinese. They are a Taiwanese company.

Though with the WTO ruling, would that even be necessary? If they are going to partner with someone though and it not being a car manufacturer, it would probably be a partner that handles the infrastructure and power generation. Hanergy Holdings Group maybe?
 

ck1116

Member
May 21, 2014
112
15
Hong Kong
Foxconn is listed at HK Stock Exchange #2038; their factories are located at many province at China.
Foxconn is already making some Model S components for Tesla.

I think likely Tesla will partner with Geely; who has bought Volvo together with Ford some years ago. they are interested to cooperate with western company, and their mission is "make safest car, make green car." very consistent with Tesla.

- - - Updated - - -

Not matter it's import tax or other fee; China or any countries always have their way to make it much higher cost to purchase foreign cars.

E.g. Hong Kong hasn't import tax, but has first registration fee, which make car prices about double compare to USA.

Not necessary. As I said, WTO struck it down:

U.S. wins WTO dispute with China over auto imports

- - - Updated - - -

another possibility maybe BYD, HK Stock #1211.

BYD is existing EV maker in China, they consider Tesla as their major competitor.
But as Elon may release patents to competitors to create constructive competition, it may turn our BYD and Tesla will become partners.
 

evme

Member
Jul 5, 2013
615
2
NY
Foxconn is listed at HK Stock Exchange #2038; their factories are located at many province at China.
Foxconn is already making some Model S components for Tesla.

I think likely Tesla will partner with Geely; who has bought Volvo together with Ford some years ago. they are interested to cooperate with western company, and their mission is "make safest car, make green car." very consistent with Tesla.

- - - Updated - - -

Not matter it's import tax or other fee; China or any countries always have their way to make it much higher cost to purchase foreign cars.

E.g. Hong Kong hasn't import tax, but has first registration fee, which make car prices about double compare to USA.



- - - Updated - - -

another possibility maybe BYD, HK Stock #1211.

BYD is existing EV maker in China, they consider Tesla as their major competitor.
But as Elon may release patents to competitors to create constructive competition, it may turn our BYD and Tesla will become partners.


From what I understand, China has plate fees. But they made 3000 car exemption for imported EVs, local EVs are totally exempted kind of. Though would the fee alone justify it? At end of the day, if Tesla was to make a partnership. It would have to be a company that fills in the gaps that Tesla lacks, not one that complements them. As Tesla is in favor of vertical integration. Which means Tesla needs an energy partner in China. To make sure that Tesla cars are charged using clean energy and that infrastructure is maintained in China.

BYD would probably be the last pick. I don't think Panasonic wants to have Tesla seeks competitors. Because BYD is more of a Panasonic competitor then Tesla competitor.
 

ck1116

Member
May 21, 2014
112
15
Hong Kong
Tesla already allied with a Chinese solar power company to build SC stations, what they need is to make cheaper cars in China is to ally a car maker I think.


From what I understand, China has plate fees. But they made 3000 car exemption for imported EVs, local EVs are totally exempted kind of. Though would the fee alone justify it? At end of the day, if Tesla was to make a partnership. It would have to be a company that fills in the gaps that Tesla lacks, not one that complements them. As Tesla is in favor of vertical integration. Which means Tesla needs an energy partner in China. To make sure that Tesla cars are charged using clean energy and that infrastructure is maintained in China.

BYD would probably be the last pick. I don't think Panasonic wants to have Tesla seeks competitors. Because BYD is more of a Panasonic competitor then Tesla competitor.
 

DaveT

Searcher of green pastures
Nov 15, 2012
3,496
11,014
Texas
Tesla already allied with a Chinese solar power company to build SC stations, what they need is to make cheaper cars in China is to ally a car maker I think.

It's my understanding to avoid the import tariff they need to partner (joint venture) with a Chinese company, not necessarily an auto maker. This means Tesla could partner with any Chinese manufacturer, not just an auto maker, since Tesla would be providing most everything anyway.
 

CalDreamin

Member
Jun 12, 2013
439
13
Bay Area
Not necessary. As I said, WTO struck it down:

U.S. wins WTO dispute with China over auto imports

My read is that the 2 - 21.5% import duties that China imposed several years ago on some US automakers were recently struck down by the WTO. After the US bailed out GM and Chrysler, China said this was a subsidy that constituted dumping, hence the additional import duties. WTO disagreed. I don't think this import duty would have applied to Tesla even if it had not been struck down. Anyway, China stopped imposing these additional import duties last December.

My understanding is that China also imposes a 25% duty on all imported cars not manufactured by a JV in China, and this import duty was not part of the WTO dispute. This duty does apply to Tesla. I might be misunderstanding.
 

azure1979

Member
Oct 26, 2013
14
0
changwon city south korea
Tesla already allied with a Chinese solar power company to build SC stations, what they need is to make cheaper cars in China is to ally a car maker I think.
Now Tesla don't need to make partnership with other auto makers. I think Tesla will partner with other auto makers after 2020(success of Gen 3, half million per year). When Tesla build 2nd, 3rd giga factories, they will give away patents(supercharging & power train technologies) to other auto makers under the terms of exclusive contracts like sole distributorship of battery pack.
 

ck1116

Member
May 21, 2014
112
15
Hong Kong
During Elon at Beijing first car delivery event some weeks ago, he had mentioned that he plans to make cars at China within 3-4 years, not 2020; and he also mentioned that this decision is aim to reduce the 25% tax.

Now Tesla don't need to make partnership with other auto makers. I think Tesla will partner with other auto makers after 2020(success of Gen 3, half million per year). When Tesla build 2nd, 3rd giga factories, they will give away patents(supercharging & power train technologies) to other auto makers under the terms of exclusive contracts like sole distributorship of battery pack.
 

Products we're discussing on TMC...

About Us

Formed in 2006, Tesla Motors Club (TMC) was the first independent online Tesla community. Today it remains the largest and most dynamic community of Tesla enthusiasts. Learn more.

Do you value your experience at TMC? Consider becoming a Supporting Member of Tesla Motors Club. As a thank you for your contribution, you'll get nearly no ads in the Community and Groups sections. Additional perks are available depending on the level of contribution. Please visit the Account Upgrades page for more details.


SUPPORT TMC
Top