Ah one difference is I run 18" wheels on my P3D (18x9.5, 265-35-18 tires). So maybe a 265-35-19 fits on a 19x8.5 but a 265-35-18 won't fit on a 18x8.5?
265 is too wide for any 8.5" ..at least to be effective
I have 255 AO52 on my 20" and they are pretty wide. 265 would not be good
personally like 285 on 9.5" if you are not running Street class.(Staggered 255/285 on a RWD S is best)
...so want a 3 to auto X... you bastards ; P