Previous to my actual experience with this on the all-wheel-drive Performance Model 3, I probably would've recommended Winter snow tires. However there were a lack of options for really good winter snow tires in the 20 inch size (235/35-20), so I took a chance on the top-rated
Michelin Pilot Sport All Season A/S 3+. It's staggeringly good on dry pavement, in the wet, and in light to moderate snow. In fact it's so good on dry pavement I can barely tell the difference between this and the summer Michelin Pilot Sport 4S.
Here's why I think it's worth taking a look at these tires. The traction control on the Model 3 is so good and so responsive/quick acting and you have such a great 50-50 weight balance that I think you can get away with all season tires and reap the benefits of the AS tire in more moderate cold weather, when there is no snow. If I were living in Minnesota I might change that recommendation but in New England I feel very confident on these tires. The Model 3 on these tires with its all-wheel drive probably as good as a lot of all-wheel drive cars with full snows. The super rapid modulation of drive force made possible with the electric drivetrain really makes a difference. I recommend these highly.