The thing is: reality is more nuanced than that.
It is one thing to believe that Tesla can achieve Level 5 because it has achieved BEV and SpaceX has achieved VTVL. In fact, I probably would join that club — the chances are they will (barring a company failure or disruptive acquisition type of event).
But will they achieve Level 5 with the current hardware and within the timelines relevant to current cars?
On this, we have evidence to the contrary too. P85D HP failed to reach the advertised HP figures even after numerous software updates and hardware retrofits (Ludicrous). P90DL failed to reach the advertised acceleration figures even after several pack versions which were not retrofitted to older cars. In this case it took P100D in 2016 to actually deliver on the promises made in 2014-2015. All of which was little comfort to those with P85Ds and P90DLs. Those who bought late P90DLs were promised P100D retrofit opportunities (so they took delivery) which eventually came but took around half of the usual lease lifetime of a new car...
Tesla promised all Model S owners lighted vanity mirror retrofits back in the day. They never came. Buy a new car.
Elon promised MCU2 retrofit opportunities to Model S/X owners. They never came. Buy a new car.
Because there is a big, big difference if they achieve Level 5 in 1 year with the current hardware+HW3 computer (as they said at Autonomy Investor Day) or ten years after an unrelated hardware update or three. Or in any case outside the life of the current cars.
So the question is not so much will Tesla deliver Level 5, but will they deliver Level 5 to the cars we bought — and will they do it anywhere near the timeslines promised — which they have already broken many times and cars bought in late 2016 will be reaching end of usual leasing lives this year...?
On Autonomy Investor Day Tesla said they expect to be Level 5 no geofence feature compete in 2019 and have operating Tesla robotaxis without anyone in them with regulatory approval somewhere in 2020. All of this with the AP suite sold since October 2016 so our current cars (with FSD computer retrofits expected before end of 2019). So that is the current guidance we are comparing the unfolding reality with.
I def agree it’s nuanced, and there’s been a lot events recently to be more skeptical in general. However, I still see a company that is reaching far with aggressive goals. They do some idiotic things here and there but overall I see mistakes and misjudgments have to occur for such rapid growth. As the company matures over the next couple decades I would expect more refinement, more logic, planning and wisdom, if that makes sense. Sure I’ll be a little upset if neither one of my cars gets to level 5 FSD, but that is what is great about this whole topic. We all get to make personal choices to back our finances to match our convictions. While I still appreciate the value of the car and EAP in current status (even if level 5 FSD isn’t reached although I hope it to continue to improve), others may think otherwise and can choose to divest of Tesla in various forms. IE not buy FSD, or choose to bet against via stock market or trade in their vehicle.
I’m not 100% happy with Tesla as a company by the way, they have a lot of room to grow especially in service, especially down here in west Texas. I’ve had a couple poor experiences already. But help me understand, if your conviction is that Tesla won’t deliver on promises for your vehicle, what else is making you actually keep the vehicle? If I were at that point, I think I would sell the car for as much value as possible, and purchase something else. (Not trying to pick a fight, just trying to understand).
Maybe I see things too black and white and not to disregard people’s valid frustrations with the company but here’s the root of what I’m getting at.
If you think Tesla will succeed, grow and become a giant in the car/energy biz, purchase stock and invest into the company to your ability. Purchase products and future products if you want.
If you believe FSD will eventually come to your hardware specifications, or you believe there will be continued valuable improvements via HW3 retrofit if you believe that will occur, purchase FSD.
If you don’t believe FSD will come of don’t see the potential for valuable improvement with current hardware spec, either don’t purchase FSD or sell your car.
If you don’t see a successfully financial future for Tesla, or feel that Tesla has been lying to slow it’s eventual downfall, sell your stock, sell your car and consider shorting the company.