Any damage to the fender?
Not anything super obvious but I haven't looked closely. Napa didn't have a push pin that is shallow enough to fit, the Tesla one is pretty specific as far as length. I'm about to email them and see what I can figure out regarding a replacement push pin. I went ahead and took the other side off, sort of interesting but there was a TON of debris inside the body of the flap. Again it's only about 1000 miles and I don't drive on gravel or any debris, I very rarely even drive the S in the rain.