Seems Tesla still hasn't actually fixed this issue.
I have a 2023 Model Y, 5 seater, “full carpet” trunk. I ordered the “full carpet” storage bins, but the one on the passenger side still doesn’t fit correctly. The rubber bin part fits, but the lid does not.
The P/N on the box I received is 1897504-00-A, and it says it’s for "Model Y 5 Seat (Structural Pack)”. My Model Y doesn’t have a structural pack, as it’s a LR AWD built in Fremont.
On advice of my local Tesla sales guy, I ordered "half carpet" ones. They don't fit either, as others in this thread have mentioned. As it stands, I don't believe there are any bins that will bit a 2023 Model Y 5 seater with non-structural pack, but Tesla's shop suggests otherwise.