I am in a dilemma. These are the options I have for a CPO Model S.
1.
2015 85D Titanium/Tan next gen seats
40k miles
Panoramic Roof
Smart Air Suspension
AP1
Power Liftgate
Price: $50,200
2.
2015 85D Midnight Silver/Black next gen seats
40.5k miles
19" Silver Cyclone Wheels
Panoramic Roof
Smart Air Suspension
AP1
Power Liftgate
Price: $49,600
3.
2015 85D Midnight Silver/Grey next gen seats
45.7k miles
Panoramic Roof
Smart Air Suspension
AP1
Power Liftgate
Subzero Weather Package
Price: $50,200
(This has a few visible scratches)
4.
2016 90D Midnight Silver/Black next gen seats
49k miles
Panoramic Roof
Smart Air Suspension
AP1
Power Liftgate
Price: $52,000
All of them have 4 years/50k extended warranty apart from the battery & drive unit original warranty.
All of them have 19" wheels apart from car 2.
I like car 2 but would like non black seats. Car 3 has that but then it has some visible scratches and 1 dent.
Please help in making a decision.
If you are still in the market, I'll give you a small formula I use (one of several but this one is my key reference):
[Current Asking Price] / ( [End of Life] - [Miles Already Driven] ) = [Cost per Mile Ratio]
I like to use 100,000 miles but that's just me using a stable number. Maybe you drive X miles a year and plan to keep the vehicle for Y number of years? That could be your "End of Life" mileage selected.
For your 4 vehicles, the cost ratio is:
1. $50,200 / ( 100,000 - 45,000 ) = 0.91
2. $49,600 / ( 100,000 - 40,500 ) = 0.83
3. $50,200 / ( 100,000 - 45,700 ) = 0.92
4. $52,000 / ( 100,000 - 49,000 ) = 1.02
I'll pick on the 4th one... Vehicle 4 has 49,000 miles used of 100,000 (so 51,000 miles of value is remaining) and Seller wants $52,000 for it. So, that equates to a lifetime driving cost of $1.02 per mile.
If you chose say, 200,000 miles for the [End of Life], then it would be $0.34 per mile.
Either way, Vehicle #2 comes out to the be cheapest purchase across the Owner's anticipated life of the vehicle.