Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register

'15 S 85D (Titanium) vs '15 85D (midnight Silver) vs '16 90D (midnight silver)

This site may earn commission on affiliate links.
If this helps, California Sales tax(including local city tax) is 9.25% (Fremont pickup location) while WA (Seattle) sales tax (Including local city tax) is 10.1%. I am thinking of getting it delivered in Fremont and drive it up to Seattle on a weekend. Save on 2k and also experience the car first hand. Then I can deal with WA state within 30 days for registering and paying the difference in tax.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MC408
You and my brother have the same dilemma. I bought my 75D new and I would recommend to buy new .... if you can afford it. However, you should consider buying the newest Model S that you can afford, and with generation 2 auto-pilot hardware.

Let put it this way ..... as I told my brother if I do it again, I would buy the basic dual motor Model S with no glass roof (it gets hot in the summer) and auto-pilot hardware 2 but not SW active. Why? It's so darn fun driving the Model S so I rarely use the auto-pilot feature.

I would use the $$$ you saved on a dash camera, snow tires and wheels, and the extended (bumper-to-bumper) warranty that stretchs to 8-year or 80K miles.

Good luck. If you really need someone to drive your new Model S from California to Oregon, let me know. I can make the trip for you and see my son in Salem and take the train back. I do this round trip in my 75D all the times.
 
Piggybacking on this thread. I am thinking about upgrading my 2014 S85 to either a 2016 85D or an AP2 75D. AP1 has been great to me but would also like the upgradeable AP2 for future proofing the car. Right now this is a $10k delta. I am also worried about losing some range. Anybody want to chime in?
 
I am in a dilemma. These are the options I have for a CPO Model S.

1.
2015 85D Titanium/Tan next gen seats
40k miles
Panoramic Roof
Smart Air Suspension
AP1
Power Liftgate
Price: $50,200

2.
2015 85D Midnight Silver/Black next gen seats
40.5k miles
19" Silver Cyclone Wheels
Panoramic Roof
Smart Air Suspension
AP1
Power Liftgate
Price: $49,600

3.
2015 85D Midnight Silver/Grey next gen seats
45.7k miles
Panoramic Roof
Smart Air Suspension
AP1
Power Liftgate
Subzero Weather Package
Price: $50,200
(This has a few visible scratches)

4.
2016 90D Midnight Silver/Black next gen seats
49k miles
Panoramic Roof
Smart Air Suspension
AP1
Power Liftgate
Price: $52,000

All of them have 4 years/50k extended warranty apart from the battery & drive unit original warranty.
All of them have 19" wheels apart from car 2.
I like car 2 but would like non black seats. Car 3 has that but then it has some visible scratches and 1 dent.

Please help in making a decision.

If you are still in the market, I'll give you a small formula I use (one of several but this one is my key reference):
[Current Asking Price] / ( [End of Life] - [Miles Already Driven] ) = [Cost per Mile Ratio]

I like to use 100,000 miles but that's just me using a stable number. Maybe you drive X miles a year and plan to keep the vehicle for Y number of years? That could be your "End of Life" mileage selected.

For your 4 vehicles, the cost ratio is:
1. $50,200 / ( 100,000 - 45,000 ) = 0.91
2. $49,600 / ( 100,000 - 40,500 ) = 0.83
3. $50,200 / ( 100,000 - 45,700 ) = 0.92
4. $52,000 / ( 100,000 - 49,000 ) = 1.02

I'll pick on the 4th one... Vehicle 4 has 49,000 miles used of 100,000 (so 51,000 miles of value is remaining) and Seller wants $52,000 for it. So, that equates to a lifetime driving cost of $1.02 per mile.

If you chose say, 200,000 miles for the [End of Life], then it would be $0.34 per mile.

Either way, Vehicle #2 comes out to the be cheapest purchase across the Owner's anticipated life of the vehicle.
 
  • Like
Reactions: chan4mdls and MC408