I had the Goodyears (Eagle F1 Asymmetric 3 TO) for about a year on factory 22s. Compared to the TO Pirellis:
Goodyear pros:
- better grip, super sticky
- better steering response
- just as quiet as the Pirellis
Pirelli pros:
- more efficient
- slightly softer, more comfortable ride
- all-season
I didn't own the Pirelli's long enough to comment on tread life, but I wore through the Goodyears in less than 20,000 miles.