I've got a client that purchased a 1000Ah 48v 'Iron Edison' battery that I'm installing. Ni-Fe batteries had been on my radar for a while but I never had much of a reason to do a deep dive until now. I've found it fascinating AND frustrating how complex batteries are... Solar is easy... for the most part it's all the same. Silicon is Silicon. Some panels might be a little more efficient or last slightly longer... but it's really all the same. Not true with batteries. There's power density, energy density, cycle life, calendar life, material scarcity (looking at you cobalt!), ease of recycling, toxicity, maintenance, weight, gassing, what SOC does it like.......
Ni-Fe batteries are far from perfect. But they are seemingly much better at one thing... they're virtually indestructible. You can overcharge or undercharge. Charge when cold or hot. Discharge 100% or charge them 'till you're basically using them to make H2 as long as the plates stay covered. They don't care... they are the honey badger of batteries.
They do have some significant disadvantages...
I priced out a 500Ah 48v bank (~24kWh) shipped from China for <$10k including freight. It's such a simple battery I'm not too concerned about getting an inferior product. Still on the fence...
Ni-Fe batteries are far from perfect. But they are seemingly much better at one thing... they're virtually indestructible. You can overcharge or undercharge. Charge when cold or hot. Discharge 100% or charge them 'till you're basically using them to make H2 as long as the plates stay covered. They don't care... they are the honey badger of batteries.
They do have some significant disadvantages...
- Round trip efficiency of ~70%
- Self-Discharge ~1% per day (yes; ~30%/mo)
- Require more watering than PbSO4
- Somewhat expensive ~$500/kWh (from China)
- Low Energy and Power density
- WIDE voltage range. Need to charge at ~1.6v/cell; nominal is ~1.2v
I priced out a 500Ah 48v bank (~24kWh) shipped from China for <$10k including freight. It's such a simple battery I'm not too concerned about getting an inferior product. Still on the fence...