Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register

Papafox's Daily TSLA Trading Charts

This site may earn commission on affiliate links.

I'm of the opinion that the Aurora news was overplayed when Business Insider credited a 4% drop of TSLA to that news. I see that CNN picked up on the overplayed caption, so there could have been some fallout because of it, but really, this development potentially affects TSLA far enough in the future and with enough question marks that it should not significantly affect today's SP. I see the rather evil-minded Business Insider noticing two unrelated pieces of information (Aurora has some big investors and TSLA down 4% at the peak of the daily dip) and combining them together in order to create FUD. Might that FUD have had an impact on the SP? Possibly, but maybe not.
 
feb8chart.JPG

This morning was a volatile time for the NASDAQ as word came out that Trump and Xi would not meet before the March 1 deadline for new tariffs. Somewhat balancing this news was news of positive earnings by U.S. companies. In the end, the NASDAQ closed up slightly, with a big upturn in the final 5 minutes. Looking at TSLA trading, you can see clear icicle dips in TSLA that matched the timing of NASDAQ dips, but with much greater scale. Such well-defined icicles would suggests lots of manipulations by shorts today,and the 59.5% of selling by shorts today confirmed suspicions. Other news:
* Ballie Gifford increased its TSLA holdings in the 4th quarter
* Model 3 autopilot is now approved for use in Europe
* Tesla temporarily makes autopilot standard on Chinese Model 3s This final piece of news hints at two problems. First, China demand is likely weaker than desired, primarily because of a weak Chinese economy as the tariffs are in effect and because of plans for most Chinese M3 buyers to go for Shanghai-produced standard range M3s both for cost reasons and to achieve Chinese EV subsidies. The other issue is that Chinese are often used to getting their computer software for free, due to rampant piracy, and some of the "we don't pay for software" attitude might spill over to automotive software as well. Thus, autopilot inclusion in M3 orders is likely already low, which makes including it for free for a limited time less expensive than you'd typically see for a similar promotion in another country.

feb8nas.jpg

The NASDAQ started in the red but rose to a small gain of 0.14% today, with a spirited climb in the final 5 minutes

Although the short-sellers almost certainly enhanced the icicles of the morning through selling on the downward movements (and hoping to cover before the recoveries), two additional manipulations appear likely. Around 2:30pm, the NASDAQ went green for a short time, but TSLA, which was on a trajectory to go green, was not allowed to do so (whack-the-mole type of capping). Then, the the NASDAQ and most tech stocks shot up in the final 5 minutes of the day, TSLA did not, presumably because of selling by shorts to enforce the cap.


feb8short.jpg

Shorts were tagged with 59.5% of TSLA selling today, a high number that makes sense when you look at the depth of the TSLA icicles today and the lack of a TSLA rally in final 5 minutes of market trading when the NASDAQ ran for the stars.



feb8tech.JPG

Looking at the tech chart, you can see that the final three days of trading have taken a toll on TSLA's SP, but today the NASDAQ turned green in the final minutes and TSLA recovered nearly all of its earlier losses, setting up an improving trend going into the weekend.

The obstacles for Tesla are now becoming clearer. Two or three ships are heading to China with Teslas and with new tariffs by the U.S. and expected counter-tariffs by the Chinese likely to be imposed on March 1, it's a race to get those cars delivered before their prices rise sharply and Chinese buyers choose to wait out this round of tariffs before buying. Fingers crossed. Meanwhile, Pier 80 at San Francisco is seeing a steady stream of high-end M3s heading to Europe for Q1 deliveries. Vehicles delivered on the Glovis Captain encountered delivery hitches, which will hopefully be smoothed out with each new arrival. Tesla is likely depending upon Europe to absorb 20,000 Model 3s this quarter in order to make the overall delivery goals possible for Tesla. As more numbers come forward, I will share with you.

The Chinese tariffs, which are resulting in lower Chinese economic activity and in turn with lower worldwide economic activity, are the key to Tesla's mid-term performance. If a prolonged tariff war continues between the two countries, Tesla delivery numbers and margins will be affected. For this reason, it may be important for Tesla to get the SR battery production underway at GF1 soon so that the factory can continue to produce growing numbers of M3s as Fremont becomes more efficient. In the mid-term, organic demand in North America and Europe will be negatively affected if the world economic situation slows and the low-cost M3s would be necessary to keep the factory at full production. I don't think Tesla needs to offer the $35K M3 yet, though, to keep things at full production. A SR M3 with the deluxe interior for $5K more would likely be good enough to suit the needs of most low-end buyers, especially when combined with a $3.75K tax credit in the U.S. $36,250 just isn't that much more than $35K.

My guess is that the Chinese are watching Trump right now, to see how well he does in U.S. negotiations. If he is successful in securing funds for a border wall, then that development would positively influence his bargaining position with China. Similarly, if the final Mueller investigation is released and Trump survives it without mortal wounds, then Trump again gains some bargaining advantage with the Chinese. This is a contest of who can outlast who. China is likely flexible on tariff issues now but the intellectual property issue is huge and will likely need to be resolved for the U.S. to agree to a deal. For decades, the U.S. has accepted terms of trade with China that are at odds with long-term financial success of the U.S. As brutal as this tariff war is, it has to be continued until China finally blinks. In time, they must because the tariff war is hurting them far more than it is hurting the U.S.. In the meantime, this one macro issue holds great influence on Tesla's mid-term stock performance. Imagine the sigh of relief that the markets will give when a deal is finally struck. Until then, the fasten seatbelt sign is on and turbulence is expected.

For the week, TSLA closed at 305.80 in a tough macro week, down 6.41 from last Friday's 312.21. Have a good weekend.

Conditions:
* Dow down 63 (0.25%)
* NASDAQ up 10 (0.14%)
* TSLA 305.80, down 1.71 (0.56%)
* TSLA volume 5.8M shares
* Oil 52.72
* Percent of TSLA selling tagged to TSLA shorts: 59.5%
 
feb11chart.JPG

The broader indexes opened higher Monday morning on word that discussions on trade would reopen between China and the U.S., but the mood became more pessimistic as the afternoon wore on, leading to mixed macros by afternoon. Although NASDAQ peaks of 10:30am and 12:45pm are reflected somewhat in TSLA's chart, for the most part TSLA was trading on its own power for most of the day. Clearly an analyst upgrade positively affected trading, with TSLA peaking at nearly 318 shortly after 10am. The NASDAQ bottomed out around 2:50pm today and climbed into the close, while TSLA showed a slow descent after a 12:45ish peak.

What we often see with TSLA is that if it peaks too early in the day, shorts and traders will start driving it down on low volume, which is what happened today. What TSLA really needs for a great day is enough energy or a late enough catalyst to carry it uphill into close. Nonetheless, today was a good trading day for TSLA as it did 2% better trading than the NASDAQ.

News:
* Canaccord Genuity upgrades TSLA to buy and raises PT from 330 to 450
* Reports from China indicate new Model 3 orders can't be delivered until April, implying that Q1 cars are already sold out and that the free enhanced autopilot promotion had the desired effect

feb11nas.jpg
''
The NASDAQ closed up a mere 0.13% today, as TSLA left it in the dust

feb11short.jpg

Shorts were tagged with selling 53.5% of TSLA on FINRA sites today



feb11tech.JPG

Looking at the tech chart, today's gains went far to reverse the perceived downtrend from the past three trading sessions. The good news is that these gains came on rather neutral macros. Let's hope that tomorrow we see what a good macro day can produce for us.

Conditions:
* Dow down 53 (0.21%)
* NASDAQ up 10 (0.13%)
* TSLA 312.84, up 7.04 (2.30%)
* TSLA volume 7.1M shares
* Oil 52.41
* Percent of selling tagged to TSLA shorts: 53.5%
 
feb12chart.JPG

Today was a big up day for the macros but TSLA faded in the afternoon. Why? My best guess is that some traders learned early of the upcoming deal for GM and Amazon to invest in EV truck manufacturer Rivan. The rapidity of the dip took on the look of news, and I think it was. The dip makes sense when you consider the recent dip in TSLA caused by Amazon investing in autonomous driving rival Rivian. The icicle appeared for the same reason that it does in short-selling manipulations: you had buyers and sellers operating with two different beliefs. The dip in after-market trading as the news properly came forward adds credence to this theory of early knowledge of some news. The selling likely started by noon, but when others learned of the news selling accelerated about 1 pm and it was a race between insider-knowledge possessing traders to unload before the other guy.

feb12nas.jpg

The NASDAQ traded up 1.46% today and was extremely stable from 11am through close

Short percentage of selling was slightly lighter than yesterday at 51%, suggesting we weren't seeing substantial manipulations today. Looking at the "short sight" data provided by Dusaniwsky, shorts added some 345,000 shares to short interest yesterday in an effort to keep TSLA from climbing any higher than it did. Yesterday failed to offer sufficient opportunities for reasonable covering of the day trading manipulations, and so some of that short interest increase was carried over to today. Let's see tomorrow whether the shorts covered today.


feb12tech.JPG

Looking at the tech chart, you can see that TSLA is in the no man's land between resuming its climb and resuming a dip. The good news is that there's positive news in the world and another positive macro day may come tomorrow.

Conditions:
* Dow up 373 (1.49%)
* NASDAQ up 107 (1.46%)
* TSLA 311.81, down 1.03 (0.33%)
* TSLA volume 5.5M shares
* Oil 53.49
* Percent of TSLA selling by shorts: 51%
 
Last edited:
feb13chart.JPG


Today was day two of the "Rivian is going to take on Tesla" frenzy. In pre-market trading, traders were mostly positive about TSLA but after the stock's recovery from the early morning MMD got hit with another selling burst, the day's pattern became more clear. Sharp selling icicles suggested a real effort by shorts to see how far they could push TSLA down on this trumped up news, and looking at the short percentage of selling number of 60.5% today, shorts certainly were trying. Note that after TSLA dipped with the NASDAQ around 11:30ish, TSLA started getting back in sync with movements of the broader index, but at a lower price point. The big exception was the dip that the NASDAQ took after 4:30pm, which TSLA traders did not follow.

In other news, the challenge to the NHTSA's claim that Tesla autopilot led to a 40% safety improvement was pretty much debunked yesterday by Tesla's remarks that shows the challenge was a pretty amateurish effort that was contrary to reality.

I suspect a great many short shares used in manipulations were covered in the final minute of market trading today, when more than 195,000 shares traded hands.

feb13nas.jpg

The NASDAQ fell off quickly at day's end but still closed slightly above neutral (0.08%)



feb13short.jpg

TSLA shorts were tagged with 60.5% of selling today, way up from yesterday.

feb13ihor.jpg

Dusaniwsky's post shows that short interest has remained relatively stable during February, despite SP fluctuations


feb13tech.JPG

Looking at the tech chart, you can see that six of the past seven trading days have been negative, but the pattern does not look so much like a downtrend as it does a consolidation. I believe we're seeing such high percentage of selling by shorts (manipulations) because there are some deep pocketed individuals who are determined to see Tesla pay off their March notes in cash, so as to keep Tesla's cash position as low as possible in the hope that this move slows down the company and makes it more vulnerable. Fortunately for Tesla, it's excellent cash flow these past couple of quarters suggests the company will do just fine paying the full note in cash.

As with many, I think the market is waiting to see just how strong Model 3 demand is over time and if Tesla can continue to deliver large numbers of Model 3s profitably. My guess is that Europe will be strong and we've already seen that Model 3 appears sold out in China for Q1, so that country is showing strength. The big question is how well North America will do this quarter. If numbers are satisfactory, then the stock will respond favorably. All indications are that Tesla is producing Model 3s at a high rate now, possibly above 6,000 per week. Continued improvements in production will lead to cost gains (think economies of scale) and bring Tesla closer to profitably selling the SR M3.

Conditions:
* Dow up 118 (0.46%)
* NASDAQ up 6 (0.08%)
* TSLA 308.17, down 3.64 (1.17%)
* TSLA volume 5.1M shares
* Oil 53.99
* Percent of TSLA selling tagged to shorts: 60.5%
 
Last edited:
Just FYI, to anyone who's still holding out hope, the ship on the convertible bonds has pretty much sailed. The stock price would need to go to the ATH and stay there for the next two weeks in order for people to justify converting. Bondholders will take their money (and not convert) if the price just ends above $360 by the end of the month. The reason is that if you choose to convert, Tesla will repay:
A) half of your bond value in shares (at a price of ~360), and
B) half in the cash value of the same number of shares based on the avg VWAP for the month of Feb (roughly speaking) which will also break even ~360. So far that avg is currently sitting somewhere around 310. So the price would need to jump to 410 tomorrow, and stay there for the rest of the month to move the amount Tesla would pay in cash up to break even. In truth the price probably only needs to go to and hold ~390 tomorrow for people to convert since it raises the value of the shares from part A above breakeven, but the longer that doesn't happen, the higher that required SP goes. And theres no real catalyst for that kind of move before the Model Y reveal. And even then, that would only be a catalyst if Tesla gets a half billion dollars in reservations from the launch.

So basically, at this point, I can almost guarantee you that Tesla will have to settle this debt in cash to the tune of ~$921M.
 
Just FYI, to anyone who's still holding out hope, the ship on the convertible bonds has pretty much sailed. The stock price would need to go to the ATH and stay there for the next two weeks in order for people to justify converting. Bondholders will take their money (and not convert) if the price just ends above $360 by the end of the month. The reason is that if you choose to convert, Tesla will repay:
A) half of your bond value in shares (at a price of ~360), and
B) half in the cash value of the same number of shares based on the avg VWAP for the month of Feb (roughly speaking) which will also break even ~360. So far that avg is currently sitting somewhere around 310. So the price would need to jump to 410 tomorrow, and stay there for the rest of the month to move the amount Tesla would pay in cash up to break even. In truth the price probably only needs to go to and hold ~390 tomorrow for people to convert since it raises the value of the shares from part A above breakeven, but the longer that doesn't happen, the higher that required SP goes. And theres no real catalyst for that kind of move before the Model Y reveal. And even then, that would only be a catalyst if Tesla gets a half billion dollars in reservations from the launch.

So basically, at this point, I can almost guarantee you that Tesla will have to settle this debt in cash to the tune of ~$921M.

Yes, the cash payment is pretty much a sure thing, but Tesla and most of us are okay with that. The company has enough cash and is generating enough free cash flow every quarter to be able to afford the payment. What bugs me is Adam Jonas declaring that Tesla either needed to raise cash in Q4 18 or needs to take on a strategic partner now. Jonas follows a self-serving pattern, trying to stir up an equity raise that Morgan Stanley would help sell or declaring that Tesla is going to be $600 million or more cash flow negative this quarter (and not mentioning that it is paying down a debt of over $920 million. The net effect is downward pressure on the stock price, bringing the price closer to his 283 target. Then good news comes from Tesla, the SP goes back up again and the cycle repeats.
 
feb14chart.JPG

Today was a somewhat uneventful trading day with a negative spin put on in pre-market trading that held up for most the day. Macros were mixed, with Dow down and NASDAQ closing just above neutral. The Nasdaq rose in the morning and mostly was level in the afternoon, which would normally be a good trading environment for TSLA.

In many ways I think TSLA is in the duldrums right now with no clear direction until news intervenes. A few days ago when TSLA descended towards 300 it had a nice bounce and we're getting close to that point again.

The NASDAQ has been positive on some of these descending TSLA days, and I think the descent continues to be pressure on the stock price by Tesla's foes. We're seeing extra effort to deceive on the cash flow issue. Yesterday, Adam Jonas said on CNBC that Tesla could burn a billion dollars in Q1, but he didn't even mention that the company would be paying down a $920m note, and even at that his numbers are likely pessimistic by many hundreds of millions. Then Reuters felt left out of the action so it wrote this story about Billionaire hedge fund operator Stanley Druckenmiller buying nearly $100m in TSLA puts in Q4. The story allowed Reuters to take this cheap shot: "Tesla has $920 million in convertible debt coming due on March 1, which is expected to put pressure on the company, which has previously struggled to maintain a positive cash flow." Saying Tesla has struggled to maintain a positive cash flow (with it's two billion dollar cash flow quarters just now behind it) is like saying Dolly Parton has struggled to fill out the top of her blouse. Ah.... no.

There's a vague worry in many Tesla investors as Tesla demonstrates how much demand for $42K+ M3s is out there in the U.S. after the tax credit has decreased and the reservations list now mostly consists of intended SR M3 buyers. My guess is that Tesla will do what's necessary to keep the factory hopping and extract decent GMs from these vehicles, even if it needs to spend an extra week or two building foreign M3s before shifting back to U.S. M3s at quarter's end. As long as that vague worry is out there, though, there's plenty of investors on the sidelines and the FUD plus stock manipulations can pull the SP down a few dollars on a relatively calm day like today.

Meanwhile, nine ships have departed San Francisco's Pier 80 with Teslas destined for either China or Europe, and more are soon to join them.

feb14nas.jpg

The NASDAQ gained a smidgen but closed near neutral.

feb14short.jpg

TSLA shorts were tagged with 57.5% of the selling today, still a high number indicating quite a bit of potential manipulations.


feb14tech.JPG

On the technical chart, you can see the last time TSLA descended below 300 it ran up to near the day's high by close of trading and then rallied the next day. Any time an important dip is defeated we tend to see fuel for a short rally as a reaction to that defeat, and it'll be fun to watch what happens if macros are reasonable tomorrow and the SP momentarily dips below 300. Deja vu all over again? I hope so.

Conditions:
* Dow down 104 (0.41%)
* NASDAQ up 7 (0.09%)
* TSLA 303.77, down 4.40 (1.43%)
* TSLA volume 5.2M shares
* Oil 54.64
 
feb15chart.JPG

Friday was a big day for the Dow, up 1.74% but a much lower up day for the NASDAQ, up 0.61%. Tesla's gain of 1.35% was better than that of most tech stocks I follow today. TSLA loosely followed the trajectory of the NASDAQ today and we saw a robust 97K shares traded in the final minute.

This week was the 8th straight gain for the Dow, suggesting that worries of either a recession are diminishing and hopes of a tariff agreement between the U.S. and China are increasing. Confidence in stocks will hopefully translate into confidence in the economy and this confidence is important for robust buying of new vehicles.

feb15nas.jpg

The NASDAQ closed up 0.61% on Friday, much less than the Dow's rise


feb15shorts.jpg

For the second day in a row, short percent of selling decreased, this time to 54.5%. A likely reason for the decline? The macros have been turning bullish and it's much harder to make money with TSLA manipulations when macros are heading upward.


feb15tech.jpg

To put things in perspective, consider this TSLA chart dating back into October. We see the full range of trading, from the lows slightly below 250 to the highs approaching 380. Halfway between these numbers is 315, which is approximately where the red 200 DMA resides at present. You can see that TSLA's present price is conservative, both in terms of the trading range and in recognition of the past two quarters of massively cash flow positive operations. The trading range has been so narrow over the past 2 1/2 weeks that the upper and lower bollinger bands are running in towards the center.

Now, to put this 250 to 380 trading range into perspective, let's look at the chart below.

feb15revenue.jpg

You can see that what looks like massive price swings is rather tame compared to the rate at which Tesla's revenues have been climbing since 2014. The progress that Tesla has been making in expanding its business is all too clear by the revenue increases, but the stock price graph lags far, far behind. Implications? The obvious conclusion is there's massive upside to TSLA once investors recognize that the company's progress in becoming a profitable entity with massive growth is intact.

Unfortunately, the media has been keen to echo all of the Tesla bear points, with one of the largest being that Q3 will be the best quarter Tesla ever sees. Q4 fell slightly short of Q3 in profitability but exceeded Q3 in various other metrics and Elon has warned that Q1 19 might barely be profitable, and so the market's jury is still out about Tesla's ability to grow its profitability.

There are two ways to remedy this situation: reducing costs to make the standard range Model 3 profitable or demonstrating that organic demand is sufficient to continue growth with the higher-end variations of Model 3. In all likelihood, what we'll see from Tesla is a mix of these two solutions: first with profitable expansion to worldwide deliveries of Tesla's high end M3s and then by summer the profitable introduction of the Standard Range (SR) Model 3. Worldwide demand is not being affected by the expiration of full U.S. tax credits on the vehicles. Both European and Chinese demand look good for the high end M3s right now in Q1. In Q2 right-hand drive M3s begin to be sold. By summer, Tesla will likely have take steps to profitably offer the SR M3, but there's no rule that the $5K pup option must go away at the initial introduction of SR M3, however, and so Tesla appears to have a lot of wiggle room to buy time while it continues to cut production costs on M3. Economies of scale at 7K M3s/wk will be part of that solution.

Let's now look at specific catalysts that will bring Tesla and Model 3 to sustained profitability.

* Surprise Q1 production rate- Tesla has guided for M3 production rate to hit 7k/wk by the end of the 2019. Various sources suggest Q1 production is already well above Q4 production and climbing. Looking at the Bloomberg Model 3 tracker site, I see an estimate of 42K M3s produced halfway through Q1. That's a rate of nearly 85K for the quarter and production rate is still increasing. Model 3 VINs says that 13,225 new M3 VINs were just registered with NHTSA. Looks like Fremont factory is cranking! High production will lower costs and will lead to better profitability.

* When the China tariff wars are finally concluded, Chinese demand for high end M3s will benefit from a tariff reduction and worldwide demand will grow as economies react to better performances of both the U.S. and Chinese economies. Expect to see a sizable increase in TSLA SP when the China tariff wars are concluded.

* When Tesla's Full Self Driving (FSD) features become available to enhance the driving experience sometime in 2019 (but still falling short of actual self-driving), Tesla will be able to take a profit on a portion of the revenue it has already collected from customers for this software. Expect to see the 3.0 hardware installation signalling that a robust software upgrade and the ability to realize some revenues as profits is not far off. When FSD features are demonstrated and made available for Tesla owners to beta-test, Tesla's autonomous driving efforts may well start to be registered as valuable by investors and we'll start to see SP appreciation based upon value given to FSD.

My best guess is that production will be well above what most analysts were expecting for Q1. I would not want to be sitting on the sidelines nor be short on TSLA right now with these developments and this low stock price. An imposition of tariffs by the U.S. and China would cause a temporary dip in the SP, but chances are in favor of the U.S. and China holding back on steep tariffs again while the two sides hammer away on an agreement.

For the week, TSLA closed at 307.88, up 2.02 from last Friday's 305.80. Have a great 3-day weekend. TSLA resumes trading on Tuesday.

Conditions:
* Dow up 444 (1.74%)
* NASDAQ up 45 (0.61%)
* TSLA 307.88, up 4.11 (1.35%)
* TSLA volume 3.9M shares
* Oil 55.98
* Percent of TSLA tagged to shorts: 54.5%
 
Last edited:
As the 3-day weekend winds down we get ready for Tuesday's trading. It's a shame that a Commerce department study came out that declares foreign cars as a threat to America. By Friday, multiple sources indicating a nice jump in Q1 M3 production over Q4 likely would have buoyed the SP this coming week. Instead, the shorts and the media have another negative story to run with, and so we'll likely take a hit for that news on Tuesday.

My guess is that the study was designed to reach this conclusion so as to give Trump a bargaining chip with the Europeans on various other issues. Let's hope the two sides work out a deal so this bargaining chip never gets implemented. The timing of the announcement is such that it might indirectly affect the China negotiations by suggesting China is better off with a deal than suffering the consequences. We live in interesting (and volatile) times.
 
As the 3-day weekend winds down we get ready for Tuesday's trading. It's a shame that a Commerce department study came out that declares foreign cars as a threat to America. By Friday, multiple sources indicating a nice jump in Q1 M3 production over Q4 likely would have buoyed the SP this coming week. Instead, the shorts and the media have another negative story to run with, and so we'll likely take a hit for that news on Tuesday.

My guess is that the study was designed to reach this conclusion so as to give Trump a bargaining chip with the Europeans on various other issues. Let's hope the two sides work out a deal so this bargaining chip never gets implemented. The timing of the announcement is such that it might indirectly affect the China negotiations by suggesting China is better off with a deal than suffering the consequences. We live in interesting (and volatile) times.
I get that shorts will use the threat of a foreign car tariff to attack TSLA because they have nothing else, but wouldn't that be a boon to domestic sales? Other than the Bolt (do they still sell that?) the only distant competition is from foreign EVs and foreign ICE cars. At some point even the typical clueless uninformed investor is going to see these lying morons for what they are.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jbih
I think a prolonged tariff of 25% on imported vehicles is not likely to happen. The big European automakers would be devastated by such a tariff and some type of deal would be worked out. My guess is the threat would be short-lived, but during that time people who are intent on a European luxury car are more likely to wait for an end to the tariff than buy an American car, even a Tesla. We saw the waiting with China, and only when the worst of the tariff fell and Tesla offered a good deal did the Chinese buyers start buying Telsa again. I suspect few buyers simply switched to Chinese autos during this time. They simply waited it out. It works both ways.This is why Elon declared that all the high-end Model 3s will be made in America in the future. Chinese buyers might have just waited to purchase until they could get a Shanghai made Tesla without any tariff and with Chinese subsidies.
 
feb19chart.JPG

Today was an interesting examples of the positive and negative pulls on TSLA pretty much cancelling each other out. On the one hand, the fear that the market would freak out about the Commerce Department conclusion regarding foreign vehicles being a threat was apparently overplayed in the main TMC forum this past weekend. U.S. auto manufacturer stocks generally closed up today, and even BMW closed higher. That's not to say that a few bears didn't run with the news, but the reaction has been pretty measured so far. Perhaps part of the reason for the calm was that the markets were generally up today on word that Trump's negotiations with China are going well enough that the POTUS is considering flexibility regarding the March 1 deadline before new tariffs go into effect.

News on Friday plus news through Tuesday continues to suggest Tesla is turning out considerably more Model 3s than in Q4. Whereas Tesla guided for 360-400,000 vehicles produced in 2019 during the Q4 ER, today Elon tweeted a photo of 4,000 Model 3s ready to ship from San Francisco Pier 80 to Europe, then he followed up with a statement that in December, 2019, Tesla should be producing at an annual rate of around 500,000 vehicles (he clarified an earlier tweet). Also, the Bloomberg Model 3 Tracker continues to show higher weekly M3 production numbers for the previous 13 week period, and the month and a half long plateau of average weekly production has now turned into a climb again. Please take the weekly output levels (showing over 8K/wk M3) with a big grain of salt because Tesla's not doing that yet. Again, I suspect the high weekly numbers are being used to bring the average production numbers to a level which is more in line with present best guess numbers.

feb19elon.JPG


feb19bloom.jpg


Then came the Ark Invest podcast with Elon Musk later in the day. It is short and I suggest listening to it. Elon was upbeat about future delivery numbers is 2021 and long term, but most of the interview was spent talking about autonomous driving. We learned that the new autopilot board is about to enter production. Elon also said that the full feature set of Full Self Driving should be available this year but it will likely be late next year before the reliability has hit a point where it may make sense to sleep while the car is underway. For us investors, the significance of the full feature set being available is that it should significantly increase the take rate of FSD plus past and present FSD purchases could then be applied towards profits when the features are released.

feb19nas.jpg

The NASDAQ climbed until 3pm but then descended into close for a mere 0.18% gain

Comparing the TSLA chart to the NASDAQ's, you can see that Tesla's descent in the final half hour was considerably steeper than the NASDAQ's, suggesting that shorts were busy turning the afternoon dip into a sticky dip on steroids.


feb19short.jpg

Shorts were tagged with 55% of TSLA selling today, still in a range suggesting plenty of manipulations. In many ways TSLA's trading today resembled a full day of whack-the-mole behavior designed to keep TSLA from rallying.

Conditions:
* Dow up 8 (0.08%)
* NASDAQ up 14 (0.19%)
* TSLA 305.64, down 2.24 (0.73%)
* TSLA volume 4.2M shares
* Oil 56.38
 
Last edited:
feb20chart.JPG

We do indeed live in interesting times. Tesla's general counsel announced his departure after only two months on the job, giving the media and the bears ammunition to claim the sky is falling. In reality, the primary reason why executive departures are supposed to be bad is because they indicate that executives are jumping ship to cash in their options and make for the hills while there's still time. When the executive departures have been going on for so long, however, the reason is obviously something else, and we all know what that something else is likely to be. Elon works himself like a slave, and he expects other top officials to show an extremely high level of dedication to Tesla. One of the country's top trial lawyers who comes to a corporation and is expected to hustle like a worker bee is going to experience instant shock, and with a retreat to the firm still available to him, Tesla's general counsel took it. We learned zero about Tesla's prospects for the future, but the stock fell a few dollars, all the same.

Looking at the trading, you can see in pre-market trading when news hits about the attorney's departure and then the stock price recovered to move slightly into the green after opening. Alas, the shorts could not let a moment like this get away and so you see the telltale icicles of manipulative selling throughout the day. Notice, too, that fully 62% of TSLA selling was tagged to the shorts today, confirming what the icicles were telling us, which is that the shorts were busy at work trying to push TSLA down and make longs believe that it was other longs selling out of fear of Tesla's latest executive departure. Nope, that is indeed a false story being projected by the manipulations of the shorts. Check out the selling of 52K shares at 11:33am and 51K shares at 12:29pm. These are ENORMOUS selling spees that temporarily depress TSLA and then it recovers. Top off these actions with over 150K shares trading hands in the final minute of market trading. I'd bet you a Tesla flame-thrower that a good portion of the buying here was from shorts covering after their daily manipulations.

feb20nas.jpg

NASDAQ's trading was volatile today, with fluctuations above and below the red/green line and a close at nearly no change.

feb20short.jpg

Shorts were tagged with 62% of TSLA selling today, and the manipulations were quite apparent

feb20tech2.JPG

Looking at the tech chart, since Christmas, we've seen TSLA touch or approach 300 from above six times. In five of those six cases the stock spent no more than 2 days below 300 before climbing back up. Thus, 300 has been working so far as a pretty strong point of support.

Since today's dip was really a manipulation and since TSLA once again bounced back above 300, I picked up 100 shares with my trading funds because I believe we have a good chance of bottoming out here.

One more point about the attorney's departure is that notice of the departure came right after Elon tweeted 500,000 Teslas to be produced this year and then backed that tweet down to mean 500,000 annualized production rate at end of 2019. You can interpret these activities in close proximity as either coincidence or a reaction of the attorney to Elon making a material Tweet that could endanger his standing with the SEC and then Elon walking it down to an innocent meaning. Which is correct? I'm not sure, but the original tweet adds credence to the theory that Tesla's production has really picked up in 2019. One more piece to the puzzle? Tesla is talking about leasing Teslas to employees. Leasing is a demand lever and if production has increased really dramatically in the slowest sales quarter of the year, the beginning of leasing may in fact back up the supposition that we're seeing a very substantial increase in production. A Feb 20 report by Alpha Hat Research suggests Tesla deliveries have been under-reported so far this quarter. Thus, we need to focus on both production rate and ability to deliver these vehicles in North America if we're going to get a good handle on how Q1 is shaping up.

Conditions:
* Dow up 63 (0.24%)
* NASDAQ up 2 (0.03%)
* TSLA 302.56, down 3.08 (1.01%)
* TSLA volume 7.1M shares
* Oil 57.17
* Percent of TSLA selling tagged to shorts: 62%
 
Last edited:
Things are getting interesting. Option sniper suggests that smart money is accumulating TSLA prior to the March 1 payoff date of the note because they're expecting the price to roll upwards.
feb20optsnipp.png


Also, word is out this evening about China and the U.S. outlining their positions for a possible deal in the tariff war. Tomorrow should be a green day.
 
Things are getting interesting. Option sniper suggests that smart money is accumulating TSLA prior to the March 1 payoff date of the note because they're expecting the price to roll upwards.
View attachment 379246

Also, word is out this evening about China and the U.S. outlining their positions for a possible deal in the tariff war. Tomorrow should be a green day.

As much as I hope he is right, this isn't the case. The stock has to be at and stay over $400 starting tomorrow to convert (it's based on VWAP). Smart Money knows that this is close to impossible. Also, TSLA gained +2129 new holders on Robinhood today, on a red day, which may suggest institutions have been selling to retail.

Robintrack

However, looking at this chart, it seems that Robinhood users are pretty darn smart. # of users holding Tesla drops when Tesla shows strength, and increases when the stock is weak. Are retail investors the real "Smart Money"?
 
  • Disagree
Reactions: MP3Mike
As much as I hope he is right, this isn't the case. The stock has to be at and stay over $400 starting tomorrow to convert (it's based on VWAP). Smart Money knows that this is close to impossible. Also, TSLA gained +2129 new holders on Robinhood today, on a red day, which may suggest institutions have been selling to retail.

Robintrack

However, looking at this chart, it seems that Robinhood users are pretty darn smart. # of users holding Tesla drops when Tesla shows strength, and increases when the stock is weak. Are retail investors the real "Smart Money"?

Option Sniper wasn't betting that TSLA actually gets high enough to enable the 50/50 cash/stock split. He was just pointing out that he thinks there's going to be pressure upwards. The jury is still out but the March note coming due has been a longtime bear argument and when it disappears without a hitch that could be a catalyst for more optimism toward Tesla. There's also the issue of the Moody's upgrade being earned with 5000 M3/wk achieved beyond doubt now and note paid in full, but it's anyone's guess when that upgrade will actually come.

A few days ago in the main investing forum someone went to the effort of graphing the percentage of TSLA that is owned by institutional investors, and it has been on the upswing. My suspicion is that many small investors have been worn out by the yoyo trading of TSLA over the past few years and many have thrown in the towel. In this regard, the shorts have enjoyed some success by chasing away investors through their techniques that result in TSLA running up and down between lower and upper bollinger bands for about three years without really going anywhere. No stock trades like TSLA and I think it's to a large degree a result of both bulls and bears feeling strongly about their position while Tesla lacked profitability numbers that could lead to more concrete decision-making by both sides. Now things are changing and I hope as many of us longs as possible are still hanging in there when TSLA finally breaks out of this aged trading range and starts exploring the wide, wide world about $400.
 
Just bought 100 additional shares at 296. This reaction to the Consumers Report story is an overreaction. As Tesla pointed out, the data for the story was from a year to five months ago and since that time Tesla has already addressed many of the issues contained in the story. The lower bollinger band right now is at 291.xx,which should be nice support, so if there's another surprise piece of bad news the downside is limited, whereas the upside can be quite high.

Edit: Hmm, the price action is getting pretty ridiculous as the shorts jump in and see how far they can push it down.

feb21lowerbb.JPG

Here's the current trading with the lower bollinger band at 290.54. Wishing I had more dry powder.
 
Last edited:
feb21chart.JPG

My original thoughts were that today was going to be green for Tesla. With 300 working well as support and with expectations of progress being made in the China tariff war, I expected things to go well. Alas, the trade talks progress was not picked up by much of the media and with some earnings down, macros were red and TSLA was flying against a headwind but gaining ground and in early afternoon looked about ready to go green and throw a life preserver to my prediction. Alas, Consumers Report decided it was time to cut Tesla down to size, especially since Tesla's Model 3 won the survey for greatest owner satisfaction of any vehicle award. Consumer Reports removed its buy rating from Model 3, which caused the stock price to tank. As the media picked up the story and as shorts jumped in to add steroids to the dip, TSLA descended throughout the afternoon to close right above the lower bollinger band, which has proven in the past to be very powerful support.

As a Model 3 owner, I have a good feel for the reliability of this vehicle and it runs circles around Ice cars when it comes to likelihood of reliably transporting you to your destination. It's a shame that Consumer Reports went against their own values of giving priority to drive train issues and instead felt that because of some reports from 5 to 13 months ago of trim and glass issues, Model 3 needed to become a target. Tesla responded to the downgrade and spelled out that most these issues were already addressed. Tesla offers a complete refund to buyers if they're not happy with the car presented to them, and so I think few buyers will run for the hills because CR says there used to be some trim and glass issues with Model 3.

feb21short.jpg

Shorts were tagged with 56.5% of TSLA selling today, a high amount suggesting plenty of manipulations


feb21tech.JPG

Looking at the tech chart you can see that the combination of super-high short-seller percentage of TSLA selling over the past few weeks plus a significantly unfair attack from CR has led TSLA down to the lower bb, even though Tesla is producing record numbers of excellent vehicles, ships are whisking them to China and Europe, and trade talks look promising with China. The year looks very positive for Tesla, and with the SP sitting on the lower bb for rather silly reasons, I have emptied my trading funds by buying more stock this afternoon. It's time to just sit back now and let the year unfold. That's the good news of such a crazy trading day. Consider today as a gift if you have some dry powder and were previously debating whether to throw it into Tesla or not.

What to expect for tomorrow? It's common for trading to dip below the lower bb, but it's uncommon for trading to stay below the lower bb for more than two days in a row.

The main job that you and I have to do while we wait for Tesla's progress to reassert itself in the stock price is to keep an eye on production and demand. So far, so good as far as I can see at this stage of the game.

Conditions:
* Dow down 104 (0.40%)
* NASDAQ down 29 (0.39%)
* TSLA 291.23, down 11.33 (3.74%)
* TSLA volume 8.9M shares
* Oil 56.88
* Percent of TSLA selling tagged to shorts: 56.5%
 
Last edited:
feb22chart.JPG

Today was the day yesterday was supposed to be (macros up on news of China trade talk progress). The choppy trading with iceberg-like dips (they're harder to see when the trading is all green) backs up the 60% TSLA selling by shorts as indicating a great deal of manipulations as shorty is not happy that TSLA has bottomed out just above the lower bollinger band and is now starting to creep up.

The rise of TSLA from about 2:40pm until close (including the jump in final minutes) reflects much of the same pattern as the NASDAQ. The good news is that shorty lost money with his manipulations today, as there was no point during the day when a good extended dip could be used for covering. Consequently, we saw a great deal of trading in the final minute of market trading (184,000+ shares) which suggest that shorty was doing a good deal of his covering at end of day. Further, look at the nice upward slope to trading after hours.

feb22nas.jpg

The NASDAQ closed up up 0.91% and it was a positive day with the exception of a dip around 2:40pm

feb22short.jpg

Shorts were tagged with 60% of TSLA selling today, extending their streak of 60%ish selling to cover many weeks and it is likely the longest run with this type of hyper-selling that I can remember with TSLA.


feb22tech.JPG

Now, that trading graphic for today's TSLA efforts doesn't look too exciting, but it does mark what is likely the beginning of the bounce off the lower bb for TSLA. The bad news? The upper bb is only about 320 now and it'll take a while push higher. Friday of next week is March 1, which is pay-off-the-note day. One major bear argument dies a week from today. Between TSLA starting its bounce off the lower bollinger band and investors breathing a sigh of relief next Friday, there ought to be room for some SP appreciation.

For the week, TSLA closed at 294.71, down 13.17 from last Friday's 307.88, mainly due to the CR nonsense. Better days lay ahead. Have a good weekend.

Conditions:
* Dow up 181 (0.70%)
* NASDAQ up 68 (0.91%)
* TSLA 294.71, up 3.48 (1.19%)
* TSLA volume 5.7M shares
* Oil 57.26
* Percent of TSLA selling tagged to shorts: 60%