I went to a body shop near my house today and they said it's a poorly done repair. There are pain runs, the color isn't blended. It basically looks like they literally spray painted over it. It's just unbelievable. The only solution now is to repaint the entire driver side door, blend it into the front and back. This is insane and it should not be something I have to do on a brand new car.
I'm debating if I should reach out to an attorney. There is clearly a loss of value here. They have damaged my car in a pretty significant way. If anyone has been in this kind of situation, please let me know how you solved it.