Those are definitely too long and look very out of place to put it politely. IMHO you should have used the original lug nuts with plastic protective caps. Why, because you know you have the correct spec, they will not start to look bad after a year or 2 due to corrosion, they are basically free except for the cost of the caps which are a few dollars and finally you do not have to remember to carry special lug nut sockets with you.
Send that pic to Wheelwiz and I am sure they will make things right.
These are the caps I ordered, they fit snug and have never come off in over a year. Bought 3 sets, 1 for the Y, 1 for the S and a set to be used as spares in case one falls off which has not happened yet. You need to chose the 21mm size FYI.