What was your offset on the 19x9.5. I ordered them test fit just the wheel and I’m not sure if the offset is right all they had was+35 I feel like they may stick out a little. I just do t want it to rub.I went with the 19x9.5 in Bronze which looks pretty nice but my fiancee isnt as much of a fan of the color. Same size as the OEM Geminis so i was able to just swap the tires over and has less offset so its not as sunken in. Would still need another 10mm or so to be flush i think but much better then stock.
Quality seems solid enough, no issues so far but i only have like 5k miles on them.
Foam tires aren't necessary and i think alot of people put on Michelin AS3/4s, or PSS and are happy with those.
I bought mine directly from Aodhan and had a local shop swap the tires over and install them for about $80.
Might be putting mine up for sale soon and just getting the Geminis powdercoated black since thats what the fiancee prefers.