I've been on the fence about this for a while...I like the idea of having something there just to feel more like a normal car, but the price of the Tesla one very steep. I also have driven a few newer Model S's and found the center console to be a bit....weird. Just not super well designed I guess. The sliding door was kind of sticky, it seemed easily scratched, the inside cup holders seemed to be an awkward work around...BUT, it may be better than the alternatives. I haven't seen any of the aftermarket ones in person to compare.
I've been looking at
this one by evamped for a while because the cupholders look more easily accessible, and of course much cheaper, but it's tempting knowing that the official one is (allegedly) back in stock...