TSLA chart above
QQQ chart above
Health report: I'm fully over the food poisoning but now suffering fatigue after catching up on two full days of TMC main investor thread posts.
As mentioned on Wednesday, the Earnings Report contained $700 million of one-time charges which turned the report from a "shock and awe" experience many of us were hoping for into a decent but not amazing beat. The conference call let us Tesla battle-tested investors who understood the technology know that things were heading in the right direction. Below, I quote
@Sancho from
this post in the main TMC investor's thread:
1. We plan on making greater than 50% more cars this year.
2. We don’t anticipate any supply issues (batteries or chips) preventing us from achieving that
3. We can keep the sticker price where it is and sell every car we make this year
4. Our margins will continue to improve throughout the year.
5. This will be a big year for our energy business too.
6. FSD is the biggest free option attached to a share of stock in the history of the world. A significant piece of that value may get unlocked this year.
Bullish AF. Everything else is noise.
Unfortunately, much of Wall Street doesn't understand Tesla well enough to appreciate the nuances. These people need to be spoken to in a different language. Gary Black did a good job of showing Dave Lee how Wall Street would have viewed the Q4 Conference Call in
this video of Dave Lee's. Highly recommended. In a nutshell, here's what Gary was saying:
* Wall Street PMs (portfolio managers) are looking for numbers to insert into spreadsheets. When Elon said no $25,000 car for foreseeable future, some PMs will remove the expected income from that vehicle in their 2024 or 2025 income computations.
* Gary was ok with his 2022 calculations for TSLA profits, but he could see where some PMs would have difficulties figuring out 2023, 24 and 25 profits.
* PMs don't have numbers to pop into a spreadsheet for Robotaxis or Tesla Robots. Full Self Driving and Tesla Robots are not worthy of consideration on a spreadsheet in the minds of most PMs. When Elon responded to Toni Sacconaghi about how Tesla will hit 3 million vehicles in 2024, Elon responded with talk about how FSD will make existing vehicles 5 times more useful. He should have instead included that demand for current models is so strong that Tesla could reach this level with just these models plus a small number of cybertrucks. Too bad Elon didn't have
@The Accountant on the call, because
in this post he had worked out the numbers and they don't include a $25,000 Tesla.
Gary Black has retained his $1600 price target for TSLA. In this note, Adam Jonas of Morgan Stanley is
maintaining his $1300 target after the Earnings Report, as well. It's the PMs who don't understand Tesla who get worried when they can't drop numbers in their spreadsheets that yield positive results.
Emmet Peppers puts it simply here and Elon agrees:
If we only had a time machine for doing the conference call a second time.
Keep in mind that we saw slight of hand in the Microsoft earnings report when their beat was followed by an immediate 5% drop. Fortunately, that dip got unwound during the conference call, but with investors filled with fear wondering what the Fed is going to do next with interest rate hikes, nefarious actors are going to try taking advantage of that fear. Manipulations are much easier in this environment.
And so trading began on Thursday. TSLA was up in pre-market trading, as it had been following the ER (once viewers realized there were one-time charges involved) and shortly after market open TSLA started to plunge (even though QQQ was way up). Remember that we had forces betting strongly for and against this ER in the options which close Friday. I suspect a hedge fund was hitting TSLA hard with short-selling to start the ball rolling downhill. A good bear attack should include FUD to explain why the stock price is dropping. Reuters addressed that hedge fund's needs (Reuters has a track record of "timely" negative article on Tesla). When I awoke I looked at TSLA's trading on my phone and then the first news item to catch my attention under Tesla was The Reuters article
Tesla sinks after supply chain warning, hitting other EV makers. It is classic FUD in that it is technically not a lie but it gives an impression which is opposite from reality. Somehow Zach and Elon's comments that Tesla would "comfortably" exceed 50% growth in 2022 got left out of the Reuters article. CNBC then joined in with the usual negativity. The 10% drop threshold was exceeded, the SEC circuit breaker popped, and the alternate uptick rule for short-selling came into effect for the rest of the day and for Friday.
With over 48 million shares trading hands, the shorting can only go so far. What it did was to create a false market sentiment that the earnings report was actually bad and get non-believer portfolio managers and weak longs selling so as to reinforce the dip. When TSLA would hit a point of support, the shorting could be used to bust through the support.
I bought a DITM leap call option near close. I realize that TSLA can keep dropping as the macros keep dropping, but now that quality tech companies such as NVIDIA are on sale (27% off for NVIDIA), at some point investors go shopping for bargains and the dip bottoms out.
Resources:
*
@MABMAB posted a transcript of the 4Q Earnings Call
in this TMC post
The big spike in 10 yr. treasury yields Wednesday afternoon settled down from 1.85ish% to 1.8ish% at close on Thursday
Max pain on Thursday morning was 1000. I don't expect the stock price to go there, but looking at the put and call mountains in the chart above, you can see that 850 and 900 are major put mountains without hardly a call in sight. Thus it makes sense for the market makers to encourage TSLA to close at least a penny above 900 if the market starts the stock price heading in that direction. OTOH, someone put on one massive bear raid Thursday and really wants a low close. Friday's trading could be hedge fund against market makers.
It's a shame the dip is covering up the volume bar, which would be at 48.3M shares, a really high volume day. We've descended below the trading range of the previous 3 months and are close to the takeoff point for the October steep rally.
Conditions:
* Dow down 7 (0.02%)
* NASDAQ down 189 (1.40%)
* SPY down 2 (0.49%)
* TSLA 829.10, down 108.31 (11.55%)
* TSLA volume 48.3M shares
* Oil 87.33
* IV 74.5, 94%
* Max Pain 1000
* Percent of TSLA selling tagged to shorts: 47%