You cannot have both. Energy wise best is to recirculate however in the winter you will be severely fogged up or way too humid/stinky. Personally I prefer fresh air circulation in the confines of a small car. The best method is to use recirculate just to start off and then switch to circulate which most cars are smart enough to do on their own That being said, why not use the auto setting? Has worked on every car I have had. Only time I need to intervene is on colder days when an extra shot of defrost is needed where I simply select the front defrost function.