Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register

Tesla loan comparison spreadsheet - auto updates hourly

This site may earn commission on affiliate links.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Don’t waste your time with LightStream. It is a bait-and-switch. They will do everything they can to avoid matching the rate and are quite rude if you try to follow up on the phone.

I obtained an approval through Pasadena credit union, then applied and contacted LightStream for a match. They originally said it would be no problem. Then they started making excuses.

First, they said an approval in an email was not enough. Then, they said Pasadena CU required a checking account. Then, they said Pasadena CU was not open to anyone. When I explained it was open to anyone, they forwarded me to a supervisor who was very dismissive. He implied I was a problem because I called twice in one day (oh the horror!) and told me to take it or leave it. If I didn’t like the loan they offered, I should go online and click “cancel.” So I did.

Hopefully I can save you all the aggravation and hard credit pull. Don’t bother applying, it isn’t worth it.
 
  • Love
Reactions: TechSavvyWife
What rate/term did you end up with? Seems like their rates went up today before I could submit my application.

I ended up with 2.39 at 66 months but don't go by me. I am only working part time right now as part of a returning from maternity leave program so my income looks like half of what it was/will return to and I didn't want to go through all the paperwork of adding my husband for .1% difference.

I did just check and yes they jumped by like half a percent. Still those are pretty good from what I compared them to at different places.
 
Don’t waste your time with LightStream. It is a bait-and-switch. They will do everything they can to avoid matching the rate and are quite rude if you try to follow up on the phone.

I obtained an approval through Pasadena credit union, then applied and contacted LightStream for a match. They originally said it would be no problem. Then they started making excuses.

I just did the same thing and had a generally positive experience. I applied and got approval through LightStream first. I then went through the process at Pasadena Federal with the same terms and received a Pre Approval PDF. I emailed it to Light Stream and asked for a rate beat. No response so a day later, I emailed them again with the PDF requesting a rate beat and in a few hours got a reply with the better rate. I requested the funds to be disbursed and they are pending right now.

Sorry to hear you had such a bad experience with it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lairdb
I just did the same thing and had a generally positive experience. I applied and got approval through LightStream first. I then went through the process at Pasadena Federal with the same terms and received a Pre Approval PDF. I emailed it to Light Stream and asked for a rate beat. No response so a day later, I emailed them again with the PDF requesting a rate beat and in a few hours got a reply with the better rate. I requested the funds to be disbursed and they are pending right now.

Sorry to hear you had such a bad experience with it.

Man, that’s frustrating that we can do the exact same thing on the same days and get such different results. I stick by my statement that they are not worth people’s time. Maybe you luck out and get it. Or you waste hours dealing with them only to have a supervisor act like a jackass to you and dare you to go somewhere else.

On a side note, Pasadena credit union has been great and very easy to deal with. I should have stuck with them to start. No point in dealing with the jokers at LightStream. Only reason I tried is Tesla said the car was ready and I thought I could get it done quicker. Just ended up delaying things.
 
Was it easy to become member at Pasadena? Bummer they are closed saturday and sunday. My delivery is 9/30. Not sure they will approve or wait till Monday

Do they mail you cashier check?

Man, that’s frustrating that we can do the exact same thing on the same days and get such different results. I stick by my statement that they are not worth people’s time. Maybe you luck out and get it. Or you waste hours dealing with them only to have a supervisor act like a jackass to you and dare you to go somewhere else.

On a side note, Pasadena credit union has been great and very easy to deal with. I should have stuck with them to start. No point in dealing with the jokers at LightStream. Only reason I tried is Tesla said the car was ready and I thought I could get it done quicker. Just ended up delaying things.
 
Last edited:
Was it easy to become member at Pasadena? Bummer they are closed saturday and sunday. My delivery is 9/30. Not sure they will approve or wait till Monday

Do they mail you cashier check?

They probably won’t approve until Monday, but I bet you can get setup by 9/30.

Process was super easy and anyone can do it. I applied online before joining credit union. Approved a couple hours later subject to joining credit union and income verification. Took a pic of pay stubs and joined online by donating to the public library as part of the application. Approved 20 mins later. They said they need executed purchase agreement from Tesla and then they send a check directly to tesla.

The whole process has probably taken 30 minutes of my time and can be done in one day. Just waiting on purchase agreement from Tesla and I should be all set.
 
Pasadena FCU: the spreadsheet says "for the 1.99% rate this requires loan payments to be transferred from a Pasadena FCU checking account, otherwise the rate will be 2.99%. "
Could I simply set a monthly transfer from my current checking to Pasadena to have the payments come from their account?
 
Does anyone know what lienholder information to use for Pasadena Federal Credit Union? The information I received from the bank is different from what gets generated automatically on the Tesla page (when I type in Pasadena Federal Credit Union)
 
Does anyone know what lienholder information to use for Pasadena Federal Credit Union? The information I received from the bank is different from what gets generated automatically on the Tesla page (when I type in Pasadena Federal Credit Union)
I was never asked for the lien information but tesla got the right one automatically from their database.
Pasadena FCU: the spreadsheet says "for the 1.99% rate this requires loan payments to be transferred from a Pasadena FCU checking account, otherwise the rate will be 2.99%. "
Could I simply set a monthly transfer from my current checking to Pasadena to have the payments come from their account?

Yes they don't need direct deposit just automatic transfers from their checking account.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: e-FTW
lightstream is refusing to rate-beat my 'preapproval'. The letter states 'pre-approved' pending my joining the CU via a $5 donation (which needs to be mailed in via check) and funding my checking account with $1 minimum. I suppose I can go through that song and dance, but cmon.. really?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.