They are the exact same as Carwiner, Basenor, RPMTesla, Abstract Ocean, <random Amazon seller>... Same exact mud flaps.
After trying the three major brands:
- Tesla OEM
- Chinese Manufactured White Label (Carwiner, TeslaShields, Basenor, RPMTesla, Abstract Ocean, any Amazon seller)
- Rally Armor
I stuck with rally armor, they look the best, I think they're flexible (i.e. if I bottom out on something I don't hear an annoying scratch) and have great coverage. I don't like the price, but whatever, car looks great and has functional mud flaps. I would prefer the Rally Armor have a more matte finish.