1st principles thinking should not be used to try to explain every thing.
And this definitely is not one of them. (+ btw. the very use of the two examples is thinking by analogy)
I have a strategy in place, where I sold CC's at high SP, high IV and am using the monies to buy the dips.
I added that as clarification, just so peeps know that I am not using my own money in buying more.
Sure market is unpredictable, but I thought it was a good time to get in at a lower SP with lower IV. Market has moved down due to inflation and rate increases worries. At this point my thought is that it too shall pass.
(+If this trade goes against me, it will mean that all the CC's I sold went for me. -- And at some point I will be balancing my single stock portfolio accordingly)
I sold bunch of CC's when many here said not to. Now I am buying Calls when there is fear and I will follow accordingly when greed comes along. ~ cheers!!