Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register
  • The latest TMC Podcast (#14) is now available on YouTube and all major podcast networks. We covered FSD Beta's exciting v11 update, Enhanced Autopilot coming to the U.S. and Canada, and more!

Trade-in Drama, should I just walk away?

I'm angry. I feel like Tesla is supposed to make things simpler and they made it much worse. I guess this is a modified AITA post but here's where I'm at.

Placed an order on 1/6 for an MYP They gave me a very reasonable trade in quote on my M3LR of $40,100. I accepted
That quote expired in Feb and I updated my mileage and FSD pricing had changed and the new quote they gave me was $42,100.
I was VIN'ed with a delivery in early march but was traveling so requested a Hold through Mach 17.
My trade in expired on 3/10 and they prompted me for my mileage which I updated and they came back at $37,500.
I declined the trade. And my EDD was May-June
The next day I got an alert saying my EDD was 3/24-3/30 and told to schedule my delivery appointment.
I contacted Tesla and asked them if I could still add my trade.
They opened the trade portal and it showed my trade in value as $43,400 which I accepted. Then it asked me for mileage (which hadn't changed in the week since I was last prompted) and it went back to pending again (this was Saturday).
Today I log in and now they're offering me $39,000.

They won't budge. They told me I could sell the car privately and I should be glad that they came up. What kind of bs is that though? What dealer would play that kind of game with you. They take no responsibility and it takes 40 min to reach a human to talk to. I don't need an MYP, I wanted it. But I really feel like a car company shouldn't be allowed to swing $5k in any direction they want after you've reached an agreement.

It makes me want to walk away. I know there's a whole line of people behind me but what would you do?
Trade in values have been going down on a lot of cars. I only know this because In September-January I was receiving emails begging me to buy my car from dealerships. At first they started at $46000 for my Audi A5. I bought it 3 years ago for $47000. My old salesman even wanted it. The offers kept rolling in but kept decreasing some. I finally decided on the Y and thought that I better sell it immediately because it's on a serious downslope. I got an offer for $42K in the beginning of March, and then a week later I put it up on Shift, Vroom, Carmax and Carvana. Everyone except shift offered me 33K!!!! Shift offered me $38K. I ended up selling 3rd party from someone off of Autotrader for slightly more than what shift offered. Point being, the market is insane right now.. The chip shortage is clearing up and more EV's are coming out (my Audi was ICE), and it's just having a huge effect. Perhaps Tesla was dealing with these swings with your car. It's still messed up and I would be mad too, but I can see why I guess.
 
I'm angry. I feel like Tesla is supposed to make things simpler and they made it much worse. I guess this is a modified AITA post but here's where I'm at.

Placed an order on 1/6 for an MYP They gave me a very reasonable trade in quote on my M3LR of $40,100. I accepted
That quote expired in Feb and I updated my mileage and FSD pricing had changed and the new quote they gave me was $42,100.
I was VIN'ed with a delivery in early march but was traveling so requested a Hold through Mach 17.
My trade in expired on 3/10 and they prompted me for my mileage which I updated and they came back at $37,500.
I declined the trade. And my EDD was May-June
The next day I got an alert saying my EDD was 3/24-3/30 and told to schedule my delivery appointment.
I contacted Tesla and asked them if I could still add my trade.
They opened the trade portal and it showed my trade in value as $43,400 which I accepted. Then it asked me for mileage (which hadn't changed in the week since I was last prompted) and it went back to pending again (this was Saturday).
Today I log in and now they're offering me $39,000.

They won't budge. They told me I could sell the car privately and I should be glad that they came up. What kind of bs is that though? What dealer would play that kind of game with you. They take no responsibility and it takes 40 min to reach a human to talk to. I don't need an MYP, I wanted it. But I really feel like a car company shouldn't be allowed to swing $5k in any direction they want after you've reached an agreement.

It makes me want to walk away. I know there's a whole line of people behind me but what would you do?
Try carvana. I sold my Acura to them and they handed me a check when they came to pick the car up. I deposited check through mobile app while the car was being put on a truck. I appraised my car through carvana and vroom websites multiple times and accepted the offer that I liked. Prices of used cars change day to day in the current environment.
 

Products we're discussing on TMC...

About Us

Formed in 2006, Tesla Motors Club (TMC) was the first independent online Tesla community. Today it remains the largest and most dynamic community of Tesla enthusiasts. Learn more.

Do you value your experience at TMC? Consider becoming a Supporting Member of Tesla Motors Club. As a thank you for your contribution, you'll get nearly no ads in the Community and Groups sections. Additional perks are available depending on the level of contribution. Please visit the Account Upgrades page for more details.


SUPPORT TMC
Top