Because we are in the U.S. where free speech is guaranteed. So people can express opinions freely. Whether you agree or not is irrelevant. You are free to render your opposing view if the press will air or print it. Give it a try.
I am a huge free speech supporter. I worry, because it seems to be going away in these fits of PC. Idiots, criminals and racists should always be allowed to spew their nonsense. The internet has caused problems here, I think because of the inability of real news to differentiate itself anymore, and also the ability it provides for groups to organize, but that is another conversation.
Regarding Einhorn, is there ever a line to draw? He looks very respectable. Plays the part of a professional corporate executive. Is called on as a voice of authority by multiple so called news entities. As such, Einhorn is quick not to imply, but flat out unequivocally state that the entire enterprise that is Tesla is a criminal fraud. He compares it to past criminal frauds, like Enron.
Should he ever have to provide concrete evidence of this? Ever? Or is he allowed at some point to say, "Oh, yeah well guess I was wrong. My bad. Let me tell you about the next criminal enterprise I am shorting...". And if so, then why can't Musk do the same? Is the answer that Musk has responsibilities to shareholders and yet Einhorn does not, as long as he admits in the future that his so called calculations were wrong? Do intentions matter at all? Einhorn will freely admit he is trying to move the market. He is spewing what I believe will soon be revealed to be extreme lies that he has no evidence of any kind to corroborate. But free speech, so OK.
This makes no sense in the end. IMO, if you are called on to talk your book on national TV, you should be held to some sort of standard. It cannot be that any extreme lie you state as fact is acceptable in the name of free speech and your pocketbook. If nothing else, then the media that is giving you the platform has a responsibility to make you answer for what you say, when it is revealed that you are a liar. For example, in the future anytime you show your face for an interview, it will always be prefaced as to how you lied in the past.
Ah, I am just blowing air at this point.
Would love to see 3Q profit. Daily 5% hits are wearing to say the least.