Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register

12V Battery Replacement - Local Options?

This site may earn commission on affiliate links.
Age is a much bigger factor with lead-acid batteries than mileage. How many years old is it?

I received no warnings - one day my cabin lights just started fading and the MCU and windows went whacky. Then my car wouldn't start - hence starting this thread.

Menards has the correct battery size for around $130. I wouldn't go 11 days if you're getting a warning now. Also worth noting is that usually this battery replacement would be something that a service center could do as a walk-in same day, if you live near a service center, since it affects the overall operation of the vehicle.
Thanks, no Menards around here. Car is almost 5 years old, so about time for the battery to go I expect. I might spring for the Delco battery for $180 at AutoZone, as it is the right size and has the vent port. Tesla service center is a 6 hour round trip, so I'd rather spend the extra $50 than wait almost 2 weeks for them to replace it.
Thanks.
 
I just got these battery warnings today. I went over 50K miles 2 days ago... very suspicious, like they waited until the battery warranty expired to start giving me error messages. Only about $110 for Tesla to replace with a mobile appointment scheduled, but it is 11 days away. Am I safe to drive the car, or should I buy a battery locally?
TL/DR I made it fine for 2 weeks but it’s dependent on how quickly your 12 volt continues to decline

I can only give you my single data point, I had batt warning on last day of trip so drove home ~ 150 miles with no problem other than loss of usb power / dash cam and whatever else system shuts down to conserve power. Getting back into car after rest stop car did reboot (tesla logo on screen similar to scroll wheel reboot) which scared crap out if me. I cont to drive for the 2 weeks till my at home ranger appt but only to and from and I work only 3 miles from home so 🤷🏻‍♂️ . No issues (other than the mental pain of an ocd person having to ignore all the error codes ) and car never did the self reboot again. Your results can vary depending on how quickly from time system detects battery issue (low voltage or whatever it sees) to when battery degrades to point it cannot function even when continuously connected to main battery. (another issue your car will not sleep when detects low 12v so as to decrease chance of stranding you)
 
My first 12v battery threw up the warning at a little less than 3 years old (2 years ago). I went to the service center back then and they replaced it under warranty. About a month ago I proactively purchased a new battery to keep in the garage til I got a warning. Did not get said warning 3 weeks later, and luckily the car was in the garage when it went stone dead unexpectedly. I couldn’t even open the door. I swapped it out right there and then, easy peasy.
 
I just got these battery warnings today. I went over 50K miles 2 days ago... very suspicious, like they waited until the battery warranty expired to start giving me error messages. Only about $110 for Tesla to replace with a mobile appointment scheduled, but it is 11 days away. Am I safe to drive the car, or should I buy a battery locally?
There’s a mobile tech came to my home for other issues. He opened the fronk bottom. I saw him torn off a piece of tape that covered a cable. After he finished the service, he told me that my low voltage battery might need replaced next year. After he left, I checked the 12v battery, there’s still 14.5 v. In the following shop service, I told this story to the front desk. According to the front desk, they re-wrapped cable. A few months later, I got a warning on the screen, saying my low voltage battery needed to be replaced. I checked the battery. It was about 12v. My car just past warranty. From that mobile service to the warning sign showing up only took about 3 months. What can happen during this short period of time? Thanks!
 
What can happen during this short period of time? Thanks!

Your car got older and you drove more? Tesla has gotten better at detecting Low Voltage battery failures? I mean do people really think that someone is sabotaging their car, for a part that costs about $85-$90, and costs less than $130, installed, in your driveway?
 
There’s a mobile tech came to my home for other issues. He opened the fronk bottom. I saw him torn off a piece of tape that covered a cable. After he finished the service, he told me that my low voltage battery might need replaced next year. After he left, I checked the 12v battery, there’s still 14.5 v. In the following shop service, I told this story to the front desk. According to the front desk, they re-wrapped cable. A few months later, I got a warning on the screen, saying my low voltage battery needed to be replaced. I checked the battery. It was about 12v. My car just past warranty. From that mobile service to the warning sign showing up only took about 3 months. What can happen during this short period of time? Thanks!
The mobile tech changes batteries often. His guess was probably from experience and the age of the existing battery.
 
My first battery lasted about 2 1/2 years and once I got the warning I went to the service center for the next day. Now a little over 2 years later my phone app gave me a notice at about 9:00 at night that the battery needed to be replaced soon. I went out to the car to check it and to make sure that the windows were down in case there were any problems. And then gave me all these warnings about shutting down cameras, autopilot etc. The next morning the car was totally dead and the doors were locked.

I was able to do the trick to get the frunk to open. If I connect a battery tender to the 12 volt battery, will it eventually give it enough power? I also have a regular battery charger that can trickle charge or charge at either five amps or 50 amps to start a car.I would never put it on the 50 amp charge for fear blowing up the battery, but is it safe to use the 5 amp setting? Do I need to see if I can get in through the car window which I put down when I first got the warning, and somehow disconnect the power under the rear seat before or after trying to charge the battery?
I have mobile service coming in a few days, but would like to see if I could somehow get the car out of my garage to make it easier for them to work on.
 
Last edited:
I was able to do the trick to get the frunk to open. If I connect a battery tender to the 12 volt battery, will it eventually give it enough power? I also have a regular battery charger that can trickle charge or charge at either five amps or 50 amps to start a car.I would never put it on the 50 amp charge for fear blowing up the battery, but is it safe to use the 5 amp setting?
If the 12v battery is totally shot, no a trickle charger won’t do it. 5A should be safe.

But I’d just leave it where it sits and leave the frunk open. They don’t need much access to drop in a new battery.
 
I mean do people really think that someone is sabotaging their car, for a part that costs about $85-$90, and costs less than $130, installed, in your driveway?

Yes, yes we do.

Dr-claw.jpg


I'm fully convinced that Elon has a master control board where, by the turn of a dial, he can determine how many 12v batteries should fail this week.

If you really think about it, this has to be true. They're making HUNDREDS of dollars a week by doing this. Follow the money.
 
  • Like
Reactions: brkaus
If the 12v battery is totally shot, no a trickle charger won’t do it. 5A should be safe.

But I’d just leave it where it sits and leave the frunk open. They don’t need much access to drop in a new battery.

They replaced thebattery and then I went for a drive and it said my AC wasn't working and needed servicing so I made an appointment. Now this morning I am getting the same battery warning message as before, along with the air conditioning message, and it won't let me charge the car with the mobile connector. It worked for about a minute and then stopped and started giving me all the messages again and says please wait while high voltage Powers up, but nothing is happening.

When I had the problem before I took it off the trickle charger and put a 5 amp charge on it and it brought it back to life so I could at least open the doors and pop the front.

I tried the reset by pressing in both buttons on the wheel and stepping on the brake and that didn't do anything to help either

I have an appointment to bring the car to the service center in about 2 weeks for the AC problem, but I need to go away for Thanksgiving and figured I could at least drive the car.
 
They replaced thebattery and then I went for a drive and it said my AC wasn't working and needed servicing so I made an appointment. Now this morning I am getting the same battery warning message as before, along with the air conditioning message, and it won't let me charge the car with the mobile connector. It worked for about a minute and then stopped and started giving me all the messages again and says please wait while high voltage Powers up, but nothing is happening.

When I had the problem before I took it off the trickle charger and put a 5 amp charge on it and it brought it back to life so I could at least open the doors and pop the front.

I tried the reset by pressing in both buttons on the wheel and stepping on the brake and that didn't do anything to help either

I have an appointment to bring the car to the service center in about 2 weeks for the AC problem, but I need to go away for Thanksgiving and figured I could at least drive the car.
The main battery pack is temperature regulated. A faulty AC may contribute to the main battery charging issue. If out of warranty, in FL is electrified garage they are Tesla specialists. They may be able to look at it. Also, if you can access service mode and look at the Service Notifications more information may be there about what is going on.
 
The main battery pack is temperature regulated. A faulty AC may contribute to the main battery charging issue. If out of warranty, in FL is electrified garage they are Tesla specialists. They may be able to look at it. Also, if you can access service mode and look at the Service Notifications more information may be there about what is going on.
Electrified Garage used to be about a mile away from me in Riviera Beach but they closed and don't have anything near me.
 
We got the car in Nov 2018, so coming up on 5 years. All the warnings say battery failure, and they are turning off non-essential services, so none of my USB ports are working now, can't keep my phone charged or run the USB drive for the camera. Advance Auto has a 51R battery with the vent port in the right place for $180 (https://www.autozone.com/batteries-...ry-bci-group-size-51r-460-cca-51rs/750091_0_0)... hate to spend extra for something Tesla will replace for $110, but on the other hand I don't like the idea of being without the car for almost 2 weeks, so I might just bite the bullet.
Thanks!
They also have a Diehard EV battery sized for the model 3 (B24L).
 
They also have a Diehard EV battery sized for the model 3 (B24L).
They also have a Diehard EV battery sized for the model 3 (B24L).
The service technician said they cost about twice as much and don't really last that much longer from what he's seen. Now I'm getting another warning that the 12v battery needs to be replaced. I'm wondering if I got a bad one as a replacement. But the contactors keep making that clunking noise every once in a while. I've got 150 miles of range left but it's not letting me charge with the wall connector. I'm going to drive down to the service center tomorrow in my other car and see if I can get a mobile tech to come and put another battery in and then drive the car and turn on the air conditioner to make sure that I'm not getting any other messages.
 
Yes, yes we do.

Dr-claw.jpg


I'm fully convinced that Elon has a master control board where, by the turn of a dial, he can determine how many 12v batteries should fail this week.

If you really think about it, this has to be true. They're making HUNDREDS of dollars a week by doing this. Follow the money.
I say it's the opposite, most of these are being replaced under warranty. The ones paid by customers are pretty much being sold close to at cost (you will not be able to find a third party option for cheaper, even from no-name brands, and the labor they charge is just enough to pay for the technician; they lose money if you count the travel costs if using mobile service).
 
  • Like
Reactions: brkaus
I just got these battery warnings today. I went over 50K miles 2 days ago... very suspicious, like they waited until the battery warranty expired to start giving me error messages. Only about $110 for Tesla to replace with a mobile appointment scheduled, but it is 11 days away. Am I safe to drive the car, or should I buy a battery locally?

Adding one piece of up to date anecdata- 3.75 year old battery from manufacturing date, 4100 miiles on car. Always garaged in N. California.

My 12V went bad right before me heading out on a trip.

Mobile service had come out the week before for rear-cam recall, and when asked specifically if I should preemptively replace it, he said to just wait until it put up errors. I'm not quite sure why I agreed to that, because their 12v monitoring software seems to suck like a lot of their 'automatic' stuff.

Battery threw errors, but was driveable, but car would no longer go to sleep because it would not be able to restart the contactors. Drove down to service center, and they replaced it without much trouble. And no appointment. 30 minutes.

Battery was $130 replaced, and they did not warranty the battery, it was charged as normal wear and tear.
I have a 2020 M3 I got at the very end of 2019. I had a recall mobile service for a rear harness electrical cable replacement about 12 days ago, just before my 4 year warranty expired. Other than changing tires, this was the first time I had any service done on the car. I too asked if there was anything I should be looking at before the car went out of warranty and he said no. 1 or Two days after my warranty expired, and 8 days after the harness replacement, I started getting low voltage battery messages. My estimate expired, but I think it was around $350.
 
I have a 2020 M3 I got at the very end of 2019. I had a recall mobile service for a rear harness electrical cable replacement about 12 days ago, just before my 4 year warranty expired. Other than changing tires, this was the first time I had any service done on the car. I too asked if there was anything I should be looking at before the car went out of warranty and he said no. 1 or Two days after my warranty expired, and 8 days after the harness replacement, I started getting low voltage battery messages. My estimate expired, but I think it was around $350.
Sounds like a 12 volt battery needs replacing. Nothing to do with a harness. Any 51R works or go to Tesla. There are lots of DIY videos including on the Tesla web site to do the battery change.
 
  • Like
Reactions: android04