I have Costco and pay $467 for MYLR, $557 for a M3P, and $967 for a MSP for 6 months with a $500 collision/$100 comp deductible. I also pay $600 for 12 months of home insurance. AAA and Allstate were double even when combined. Tesla insurance is like 20 percent higher but then my home would double since it’s standalone so the difference is substantial.
I got rid of my last non plug-in vehicle in 2018 (Ford Fusion hybrid) and my last ICE car (Chevy Volt) in 2020 and both were about the same in cost to insure as my Plaid and much more than my 3 or Y. Go figure.