Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
  • The latest TMC Podcast (#14) is now available on YouTube and all major podcast networks. We covered FSD Beta's exciting v11 update, Enhanced Autopilot coming to the U.S. and Canada, and more!

Article on costs of EV compared to ICE

Coming back to this article....

When I first looked at the "analysis", I was still in the order queue waiting for my LRMY to show up. I got it on November 5th and after a few months of ownership, I can provide my experience as a "mostly home charger". I thought this might be useful for others that are still waiting for their car and wondering if there were any grains of truth in that article.

1) I've used the Tesla Supercharger network a total of 7 times in those 3 months. Once was for about 2 minutes just to test that it worked. The other 6 were for a 500 mile (each way) road trip where I had to stop 3 times each way. I was fortunate to be able to participate in the 1000 miles referral program, so I don't know what the cost would have been if it weren't free. However, the 5 of the 6 stops were no more than 1 mile out of the way. One was likely 10 miles out of the way as I got rerouted at the last second. Generally, charging time was around 20-30 minutes, but because the SuperChargers were at rest stops, we were generally using that time anyhow. My guess is that after the coffee and bathroom break, I had to wait an additional 5 minutes for the car to finish charging. In an ICE car, I would have used the same 5 minutes while I pumped the gas. BTW, it's also quite possible that I didn't really need to wait those 5 minutes and I could have made it to the next charging stop with just a lower charge when I got there. It was my first (and only) long distance road trip, so I was being conservative with making sure I had enough battery.

2) Other than that road trip, the only times that I use outside chargers is if I happen to be at a place that has ChargePoint and it's free. I've taken advantage of that 4 times. Note that even though it is free, the "analysis" would charge me some exorbitant fee instead as supposedly my property taxes were paying for that. Ironically, the places were I got the free charges were not in my home state.

3) The rest of my charging has been at home. I timed it, and it takes 13 seconds for me to connect and another 15 to disconnect the charger and wrap the cord onto the holder. So, let's call it 30 seconds total for the connect/disconnect cycle. My charger is mounted on the passenger side of the car, so even that 30 seconds is likely longer than it would take people who mount their charger on the driver's side of the car. I don't see how it's anywhere near possible that it takes the author 5 minutes to do the same.

4) Also, while I typically charge every day, I certainly don't have to. I'd guess that I could charge once every 5 days and be fine. So, if you figure 30 seconds times 6 charges per month, it comes up to 3 minutes total amount of time used for charging the car during the entire month. Meanwhile, I used far more time than that to go to the gas station once to get a gallon of gas for a snowblower.
This whole thing about the cost of EV vs ICE cars is missing the point of owning an EV. I did not purchase my Tesla’s to save money for me it was more about not supporting the fossil fuel industry and helping the environment. If you look at a 10 year cost of ownership you do save money with an EV, so a bonus while you are doing your part for the environment.
For me it’s defiantly not the economics because I do so few miles that a taxis is cheaper. So, firstly it’s for convenience....but there are some provisos ...eg we only have one car even if two would be more convenient....and then there are trade offs....the convenience of filling up at home against the inconvenience of looking for superchargers on long trips...etc.
But without a doubt my biggest motivation was the end of the dealership model of the car business....my last car was a Volvo and we were held hostage to the determined rip off by the French dealership that charged a fortune to not fix a Volvo’s fragile electronics. And the final insult on top of injury is the absolutely terrible way you are treated.
Looks like when you take survey they have something in mind about installing a level 2 charger in your home with charging set to off-peak plans - most likely a subscription service that I suspect they will be able to monitor. I have Tesla solar panels with 2 Tesla Powerwalls and a Tesla Wall Connector that keep me energy independent for the most part. And that’s with charging my Model Y and running my entire house, plus sending excess energy back to the grid.

Products we're discussing on TMC...

About Us

Formed in 2006, Tesla Motors Club (TMC) was the first independent online Tesla community. Today it remains the largest and most dynamic community of Tesla enthusiasts. Learn more.

Do you value your experience at TMC? Consider becoming a Supporting Member of Tesla Motors Club. As a thank you for your contribution, you'll get nearly no ads in the Community and Groups sections. Additional perks are available depending on the level of contribution. Please visit the Account Upgrades page for more details.