This looks exactly like my cover 1494009-00-AI just took delivery of a MYP (June 2021 build) and the tow hitch cover (1494009-00-C) was very easy to remove using a flat screwdriver by just unclipping two of the tabs at the top with minimal pressure, and then using my fingers to pop the cover off. I had purchased the EveryAmp tool in anticipation but it was totally worthless as it was too big to easily slip in between the bumper and cover.
View attachment 676337
Curious what the difference is? Does it look different on the other side?