Ukrainian complains about social media:
Transcript
Hello everyone, my name is Yarema Dukh, and here is a short video about whether social networks really understand what is happening in Ukraine.
* Sweet song about patriotism playing *
Last week I was blocked on Twitter.
For the first time since 2009, I have had a problem with the social network, which I have wholeheartedly loved for a long time.
The reason is the dissemination of another person's private information without their permission.
Yes, I published a military ticket of the Russian occupier, let's call him Vlad, which was found on the territory of Ukraine.
We have had a lot of this garbage lying around the country recently. Do they have a spawning ground somewhere here or what?
Moreover, I wasn't even the source of this photo – it was on the Internet before me already.
But Twitter wasn’t convinced – they insisted I have to delete the tweet with this photo, otherwise, they refused to restore my access to their services.
Once again, Twitter is concerned about the private information of the Russian soldier who invaded Ukraine.
He invaded to kill the Ukrainian military personnel and civilians, including women and children.
1:35
But back to Vlad. I managed to get confirmation from our unit, which has his other documents, that he was not a conscript but on a contract. The contract he signed last year.
So, this brainless creature decided to join the Russian army, then invaded Ukraine, helped to murder Ukrainians here,
2:03
and I’m the one who has to worry about his privacy? Seriously?
And to worry that someone will find out his data?
And it's not just my story. Every day, my friends tell me that someone's post has been removed, someone's story has been deleted, and someone has been blocked.
In various social media. Generally, because we, Ukrainians, simply tell what we see and how we feel.
We see the atrocities of the Russian army and the Russian people. We feel great loathing, disgust, and hatred for them.
These are absolutely normal feelings in this situation.
But not all countries and not all global companies understand us.
It seems that social media were not ready that Ukrainians would write millions of posts in dozens of languages about how they feel about the war.
And what they think about the terrorist country – Russia.
2:59
Some social media understand us better and support us, and some understand us worse and ban us.
But, in my opinion, all of them still do not understand us enough.
Maybe we don't explain well? Perhaps our examples are too distant and incomprehensible for Western companies?
Okay, let's explain with unambiguous examples. Everyone knows the history of World War 2; let's use this.
The Second World War examples will help explain what Ukrainians are feeling and experiencing now.
Please like it, subscribe and send it to your friends if you enjoy this video.
What if Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram emerged before World War II? How would they look? What would be their policies?
Would the rules be the same for the people of occupied Europe as we see them now for the Ukrainians?
Imagine Winston Churchill's speech "We shall fight on the beaches" in 1940. It would be streamed live from the British Parliament on all platforms.
4:09
And imagine that this video suddenly becomes unavailable for viewing in the United States because it calls for violence, and there seems to be hate speech against the Nazis.
You can't say such things in public, be delicate with your enemies. They simply want to grab your land. What's your problem?
Or imagine a resident of occupied Brussels.
He discovers in his house a passport of a Nazi that came to kill him and his family.
But you can't tweet it because Twitter will block you for spreading Nazi's personal information.
Yes, the privacy of a Nazi who invades your country and kills civilians is very important.
Imagine being a fighter in the European Resistance Movement, which publishes how they shoot at the Nazis and win.
Oh no, this video system will also remove – you're provoking aggression! Please, don't share this sad news with people.
5:00
Imagine Anne Frank's diary, which she publishes as stories and posts on Instagram.
The girl documents Nazi crimes on a daily basis and tells what her family is going through.
No one can find her, the Nazis can't find her. That's why the Nazis are launching their bots from a bot farm near Munich.
The bots report the account, and Instagram is blocking Anne Frank's profile and deleting all posts.
Imagine if Nazi leaders had the opportunity to run their profiles on Twitter, Facebook, and other social media during World War II. What might it look like?
How would the Nazi leadership describe the Holocaust on social media?
"We entered another liberated city. Surprisingly, our soldiers found all the citizens dead. Who did it? We will conduct our independent investigation led by Obersturmbannführer Adolf Eichmann."
And how would the Nazi leadership respond to other events of World War II on social media? For example, what would you say about the Warsaw Uprising?
"Having a good time with my family and friends [in the Alps]. I am very sad that the Poles decided to blow up their capital."
6:08
Imagine those rescued from the Nazi concentration camps in 1945. They want to share their stories with the world.
There are many photos and videos to share.
So, they start posting, posting a lot.
But their social media stories are being hidden and deleted because artificial intelligence decides to.
The images are too awful; people shouldn't spoil their news feeds.
It all sounds like a fantasy, but replace the Nazis with the Russians and Hitler with Putin – and you'll get the news from 2022.
And this news is not fantasy, but stories – mine, my friends, and acquaintances. And similar cases with the social media of thousands of Ukrainians.
Perhaps you also have such stories? Email them to me – if I need examples in the future, I will use them.
We need to remind social networks that they have to respond to what's happening in 2022.
Dear social media, you need to meet current obstacles.
7:00
Neither you nor the Ukrainians wanted the war. Russia wanted one.
But only together can we stop Nazism in the 21st century.
Help Ukrainians, help the world to know the truth. Stand on the side of freedom and courage.
Update your rules. Remove the access of the Russian government agencies and their propagandists to social media.