Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register
This site may earn commission on affiliate links.
I applaud your creative thinking, but it seems like a throw back to before 1920's Fords assembly line where "workbench" was the model to replace.

I think the twist is automation. It's definitely not a near term solution, but a long term hybrid implementation might work where there are way fewer stations with more work at each.

Layer in at-station additive manufacturing and it gets even more interesting.

Right now it's more efficient to move 100 doors and 100 door-less cars to the door station as opposed to moving 100 doors to 100 car assembly stations.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hiroshiy
I just heard a reference to this on the latest episode of Fully Charged.

Daimler Breaks Ground On Tesla-Like Battery Gigafactory In Europe

Many people here keep asking where all the batteries for the non-Tesla EVs will be built. Possibly in this factory... Not quite to the scale of the Gigafactory, but a good start.

However, Daimler’s approach seems different than Tesla, as the factory will only assemble the packs for cars and energy storage systems. At Tesla cite they of course produce the lithium-ion cells themselves, while Daimler is using lithium-ion cells from LG Chem.
So no, it is nothing like the Tesla GF. This is just what Tesla did on the second floor in Fremont earlier.
 
I just heard a reference to this on the latest episode of Fully Charged.

Daimler Breaks Ground On Tesla-Like Battery Gigafactory In Europe

Many people here keep asking where all the batteries for the non-Tesla EVs will be built. Possibly in this factory... Not quite to the scale of the Gigafactory, but a good start.
Lots of companies around the world are building Gigafactories. My brother in law is working with a factory in China which is bigger than Tesla's.
Someple think there will be a glut.
.
 
Lots of companies around the world are building Gigafactories. My brother in law is working with a factory in China which is bigger than Tesla's.
Someple think there will be a glut.
.

It depends on what the demand from the public will be. When a compelling and affordable EV is available in quantity (the Model 3), that could flip demand as a larger segment of the population get to see and drive a well designed EV.

The auto industry is so vast, the GigaFactory 1 in Nevada is only going to be able to meet 1% of the world car production and that's massively scaled up from only 1/2% before the Model 3 unveil. If demand ramps up fast, as it quite possibly might, production of batteries will be way behind demand for more than a decade.

Chinese batteries can be suspect. The Chinese are capable of making li-ion batteries that are as good as anybody's and the outside companies like Samsung and Panasonic with factories in China make sure their cells are made to their standards, but a lot of the domestically produced cells in China are very poor quality.

To make li-ion cells that last and have good capacity, some very expensive equipment must be used in the manufacturing process to ensure everything is made within spec. Most cells made by Chinese companies are assembled by hand, which is a lot cheaper, but the cells usually have a short life and their capacity is poorer than foreign cells.

If a massive battery factory is being made in China, it might be intended to make cells primarily for domestic use and these might be sub-par compared to what the rest of the world expects. The EV market inside China is very strong and a lot of those cars use the substandard cells, so there is plenty of domestic demand for poor quality cells. It's also possible the cells are going to be export standard and will be good quality. We won't know until they start production.

Making good li-ion cells is a capital intensive thing and not labor intensive, so China doesn't really have much of an advantage in making good quality cells. They only have an advantage at the bottom end of the market.

On top of the demand for EVs, the stationary storage market is likely going to be massive very soon. Solar is exploding and utilities absolutely need to be able to balance their load for when the sun doesn't shine. Same thing for wind power, the need to store that energy is growing too. So even if the EV market doesn't take off as expected, the factories can always make batteries for stationary storage applications.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JRP3
Lots of companies around the world are building Gigafactories. My brother in law is working with a factory in China which is bigger than Tesla's.
Someple think there will be a glut.
.

Please tell us more about this Chinese Gigafactory. Tesla's Gigafactory 1 will make 100 gwh of cells and 150 gwh of modules when completed. Have not read about any other gigafactories underway on this scale.
 
Please tell us more about this Chinese Gigafactory. Tesla's Gigafactory 1 will make 100 gwh of cells and 150 gwh of modules when completed. Have not read about any other gigafactories underway on this scale.
Panasonic
Panasonic Opens Its 1st EV Battery Factory In China
More info on new factories
LG Chem #1 EV Battery Manufacturer In New Navigant Research Ranking

Here are the new battery factories in Europe.
Move Over Tesla, Europe's Building Its Own Battery Gigafactories
 

So, is it the new Panasonic battery factory in China that is to be bigger than Gigafactory 1? Just trying to get the facts correct. The Panasonic factory being built in China is to be 861,000 square feet. This compares to a finished Gigafactory 1 at ~14,000,000 square feet (currently at ~4,500,000 square feet). Best to state actual kwh of production and factory size in square feet if we are to compare battery factories.
 
I expect the factory he's talking about is this one:
This Chinese Battery Plant Will Be Bigger Than Tesla's Gigafactory | Inverse
https://www.inverse.com/article/32133-chinese-battery-plant-tesla-gigafactory
CATL was involved in the exploding Galaxy 7 problems:
Samsung phone revelations - bad battery design and poor quality control
The real reason(s) the Note 7 caught fire

Their batteries were the second ones Samsung tried. It looks like both Samsung batteries and CATL batteries had issues that led to fires.
 
And to think - this GF could have been built in Tucson-- with thousands of jobs and housing and all the things about vibrant growth. Instead, our politicians and auto-dealers passed a series of laws that ..well, made Tesla go to Sparks. good for them...bad for us.
If it makes you feel any better, I think Sparks is too good a location for Tesla to pass up. Though It should be a lesson for cities when future GF are looking for sites.
 
And to think - this GF could have been built in Tucson-- with thousands of jobs and housing and all the things about vibrant growth. Instead, our politicians and auto-dealers passed a series of laws that ..well, made Tesla go to Sparks. good for them...bad for us.
Politicians do what they are paid to do. It's unfortunate that they are allowed to be paid by special interests. Their only income should be from the public--and they shouldn't be allowed to set their own pay rate.
 
If it makes you feel any better, I think Sparks is too good a location for Tesla to pass up. Though It should be a lesson for cities when future GF are looking for sites.

Hadn't really thought about this much recently, but a good point...

When there are say 8,000 people working at GF1 and Tesla starts negotiating with other states for the next location, sure seems like an awfully big carrot to wave in front of the politicians. When the GF1 deal was being negotiated, those were 8,000 imaginary jobs.

RT
 
  • Like
Reactions: EinSV
Tesla couldn't build the GF1 in California because there were too many regulatory loops to jump through, but they pretty much got the plant built as close to the final assembly plant as they could. They really did get their first choice.

If the Model 3 disrupts the car industry as much as it might, states with shuttered car factories or car component factories might be falling over one another to get Tesla to move in. There are already a number of abandoned car factories around. Some have been abandoned too long to be economically rehabilitated, but others have only been closed a few years.

Tesla is talking about looking for locations for GF3 and 4 later this year. Also considering they are negotiating to open a plant in China, I would not be surprised if GF3 and 4 were in Europe and China. But close on the heels of setting up car plants in Asia and Europe, there will be a need to build or modify a plant to build the semi and all the batteries that will take. There are a few abandoned semi factories around the US that Tesla might pick up cheap, but they would probably want enough empty land nearby to build a battery plant. Ultimately they want batteries and final assembly in the same place. The same building would be ideal, but they could probably deal with a few miles apart if they got a running start on the final assembly space.

By setting up semi or car manufacturing in a town that recently had a plant that closed, there will be a pool of experienced workers they can draw on to get production started.

Because Tesla is going to be focused on automation more than any other car/truck maker in the future, there will ultimately be fewer jobs than the old plants employed, but it would help the communities a bit. Tesla is likely going to pay better than Walmart and manufacturing jobs bring money into a community from outside, where communities with just retail jobs tend to just re-circulate money already in circulation within the community.