There's a lot of concern in traditional diplomatic circles about Trump's negotiating skills, especially his tendency to impulsive behavior and simple solutions in complex situations. Withal he is reported to get most of his information from TV and even shuns reading the daily intelligence report. (That was the job of Porter and/or Kushner until the latter lost his top secret clearance.)
These concerns may be overstated. Deep down, bullies are really fearful cowards. When they are lucky they eventually can be rescued by changing the frame of reference from a test of deadly force to a symbolic fight of less import. In nature we have examples of peacocks who strut around in beautiful displays of dignity as they parade. Neither Trump nor Kim would win a fair beauty contest but they both have a flair for the dramatic and perhaps that can have a positive result.
If it happens the summit may only be a symbolic photo opportunity for the principal players in this Kabuki show. They could announce their peaceful intention by promising to support the goal of further negotiations by North and South Korea of the peace treaty elaborated above. By focusing on a peace treaty without reservations the bullies can let their diplomats work out the details and the pressure will be on them to get something more responsible and realistic done that is more than showboating. Trump's real gift is conning the public. Of course all of this will be naught if John Bolton becomes the next national security advisor to the President. His role, as with Stephen Miller on immigration, would be to maintain the traditional road to war. I remember then Secretary of State Dean Rusk being asked his solution to the problem of Berlin: "My goal is to see the problem of Berlin remains a problem"
Edit: A quick search reveals my memory of Rusk was correct and this recent study nails the dangers of preconceptions on the U.S. and Soviet sides respectively.
http://rhpsnet.com/journals/rhps/Vol_2_No_1_March_2014/1.pdf
These concerns may be overstated. Deep down, bullies are really fearful cowards. When they are lucky they eventually can be rescued by changing the frame of reference from a test of deadly force to a symbolic fight of less import. In nature we have examples of peacocks who strut around in beautiful displays of dignity as they parade. Neither Trump nor Kim would win a fair beauty contest but they both have a flair for the dramatic and perhaps that can have a positive result.
If it happens the summit may only be a symbolic photo opportunity for the principal players in this Kabuki show. They could announce their peaceful intention by promising to support the goal of further negotiations by North and South Korea of the peace treaty elaborated above. By focusing on a peace treaty without reservations the bullies can let their diplomats work out the details and the pressure will be on them to get something more responsible and realistic done that is more than showboating. Trump's real gift is conning the public. Of course all of this will be naught if John Bolton becomes the next national security advisor to the President. His role, as with Stephen Miller on immigration, would be to maintain the traditional road to war. I remember then Secretary of State Dean Rusk being asked his solution to the problem of Berlin: "My goal is to see the problem of Berlin remains a problem"
Edit: A quick search reveals my memory of Rusk was correct and this recent study nails the dangers of preconceptions on the U.S. and Soviet sides respectively.
http://rhpsnet.com/journals/rhps/Vol_2_No_1_March_2014/1.pdf
Last edited: