Well, the Canadian big shorts banks* (CIBC, RBC) have decided that they have 3 more days (until next Monday) to deliver the Tesla-issued extra shares they received to actual shareholders, so you got some followers of your logic...
*oopise, I do not know why I mis-spelled the word "banks" first.
Yeah, that was essentially my thesis back on Fri, Aug 14, 2020 when I predicted (here, in advance, that shares would runup ~80% and some Brokers would not deliver their customers dividend shares on time). There was a simple, yet powerful, theory behind this prediction. Let me explain it here again.
Big banks with brokerages (big enough to also hold Options Maker Maker status), are themselves the '
shareholders of record' for large numbers of TSLA shares (ie:
BMO Investorline holds ~2M shares of TSLA), and their customers are simply
Beneficial Owners.
What this means is that these brokers have the exemption to the prohibition against naked shorting (via the 'Madoff exemption'), and they're ALSO mostly trading stocks among their internal clients, while being responsible only to themselves for share inventory. So it's nothing but a bookkeeping detail if their inventory of TSLA is 2% too low due to their failure to locate TSLA stock in a timely manner.
These are the abusive naked shorts who would get caught by a surprise share dividend. Some of them have routinely maintained open naked short positions on TSLA literally for years.
The effect of this is to drive down the equilbrium share price, by interfering with the proper functioning of the Market for price discover via supply and demand. I wrote here on this topic extensively in Dec 2020 during the S&P 500 addition for TSLA. My simple economic model for TSLA predicted the 'addtion' SP to within $10 by estimating the number of naked shorts that would exist on Dec 18, 2020.
So the same thing happened then: A large number of forced locates and buys (~200M shares) of TSLA were compressed into a deadline, and certain hedge funds which could not easily dodge reporting rules were caught out, then forced to buy instead of playing accounting games and hiding their fails-to-deliver (FTDs). This lead to the 13-day TSLA runup which ended in early Jan 2021 (again, due to reporting requirements for FTDs).
This time, in Aug 2022, shortzes had 149 days notice of the share dividend, 2 big market swings due to macros, and those 2 previous practice runs in 2020. Not surprising they handled it this time while avoiding a 'day-of' SP runup.
But the underlying problem* still exist, and the SEC is doing nothing. $AMC $BBBY $GME
Cheers!
*
Hint: it's the
Madoff Exemption.