option 2 please.
The reason it's not popular is there will be very few of us experienced owners who want a 21 inch wheel on a car with a GVWR of 5000 lbs - you are just asking for trouble, which is why I ditched all the 21 wheels on all three Model S's we have owned. ( to be honest several wheels didn't survive the damage from road debris and potholes - remember this car has no spare - so you get the joy of paying $500 for a new tire and another $500 for a new wheel and more importantly your billable rate X the hours you sit on the side of the road pissssseeddd.. which was immeasurable as your watch your flight fly missing a critical customer appointment....arrrgghh_)
You can already see from the poll that 19 X 9 is the most popular. Also when we designed the Model 3 poll we intentionally avoided the 20's due to the known cracked wheel issues and the ridiclous weight gain. Also this size (19 X 9) was the most popular on the Model 3 too, as there are tons of good cost effective tires to meet everyones needs (All Season, Summer Sport and Winter M/S). I do believe a 20 on a Model S would be a safe option too, but I just want the weight as low as possible for better handling, less stress on the suspension and steering components, and lower watt per mile consumption. I also believe its a demographic issue too, the Model 3 buyers are younger and pay more attention to this stuff, us older guys who have kids in college, (which is only trumped by the older Model X crowd), don't really see the need for 21's, I'm not on a race track, I don't need to impress anybody, and the handling is already awesome in my P85+ on the current daily driver 19's that have been on it for 80,000 miles without any issues!!! My wife won't notice a change either in her 90D.. she didn't notice when I pulled the 21's and moved to 19's.
I think
@Flyguy is onto something, I bet the 20's would be a very popular size for the Model S, if they were added to this poll, since there is a market gap there (no competition from Arachnids and the battle damaged stock 21's) that have flooded the market. I would NEVER pay $2K for a flow formed crap that some of the other vendors are pushing on the market, when you could get 19's or 20's in Mono-block forged for around the same price.
New survey compares demographic of Tesla Model X vs. Model S buyer