I dipped my toe back in the water today. This is not an "all clear" I have no idea what is going to happen with this stock. I'm surprised we aren't in the 20s...so I wanted to put some money back to work incase I was wrong.
The 10-year story for solar is still incredibly good, so I want to make sure I have at least some exposure. I'm looking for other names in the space too if anyone has any suggestions.
Citizen-T,
Here is what I wrote in another thread:
"In short I believe that SPWR is the safer investment (less volatile) and will probably perform better the scty, so it is a win-win. Although I do admit that scty is a wildcard and has potential to do better, but I have no idea how to value that company and there are too many unknowns. There is no way that scty should have a higher market cap than spwr as of today.
Sunpower has:
- Best, most efficient, longest lasting, lowest degradation, best warranty, highest quality, lowest levelized cost of energy (LCOE) panels on the planet. They have the best technology and are introducing products such as C7 tracker that will generate 6-7x the amount of electricity from each panel, and will require 6x less land to purchase to build a power plant.
- Diversified across the entire world, and across product lines.
- Just turned profitable and growing bottom line quickly. Margins improving each quarter as well
- Stock is still undervalued at 1x Sales and 25x forward PE. Very low multiple for a growth company in the fastest growing industry in the world. I kind of know how to value this company as apposed to scty; although it is hard to figure out revenue recognition, etc.
- Financial backing by Total S.A.
- Great exposure to fastest growing markets in US and Japan.
I would encourage you to read the May 15 Analyst Day presentation by Sunpower; make sure to download the slides. It is a good company and is expecting a big second half of the year financially (according to CEO). They are also sandbaggers and give out low guidance, so expect them to beat in the upcoming quarters.
I could be wrong on Sunpower, but I think that the risk is moderate at best with a huge potential for returns. In the perfect scenario, I can see this stock going up fourfold by the end of next year, and I don't see it going down more than 30% at worse. Good risk/reward ratio. SCTY might go up even more, but I have no idea what to expect from that stock."
Basically it comes down to this: Spwr has significantly better panels than scty (uses YGE and TSL, i.e. chinese panels), they will last longer, with better degradation, and will produce more energy. I would definitely go with spwr panels on my own roof (and may be installing them soon). SPWR's lease option is also the better option from a financial standpoint too, but customers don't know this and I have doubts if they ever figure this out. Scty uses like 3% lease increases per year, while spwr uses 1%. So people may choose scty over spwr because it may seem cheaper at first, but when you factor in lease increases, degradation, etc. you would have been a lot better off buying spwr panels.
Another plus for scty is that they have the backing of Goldman Sachs and leases are very expensive, so you need a ton of capital. scty was able to install about 60k residential leases already, while spwr only installed 20k. Last quarter spwr said they installed roughly 2k, and that is only because they ran out of financing. They need to get their financing in order and I hope that Total S.A. (who owns 66% of spwr) will help them, but I have my doubts since they haven't done it so far. Therefore if scty continues getting $billions from Goldman, it will scale a lot quicker and grow faster than spwr. If both companies had unlimited finances, I would place my bets on spwr because they are superior panels for about the same price. SPWR says that the average lease is for 8.6 KW and that is limited by roof space. Scty using cheap chinese panels would only get 6 or 7 KW's out of that same roof.
Remember that spwr can also build a 500 MW power plant, that would require scty to install 100,000 residential systems just to make as much revenue.
I feel like spwr is the safer play, but scty might be the high potential/bubble play. Ride the bubble with scty, but don't get too greedy.