TSLA Sentiment Reversal and the Wealth of Knowledge on TMC
First of all I wanted to thank everyone on TMC for their relentless research on Tesla and TSLA. There truly is an unparalleled wealth of knowledge on this forum and I hope that everyone here is taking advantage of this as much as I am.
My TSLA Comeback
This next piece of information is about my TSLA purchases and how I went from virtually no TSLA exposure on Nov. 10 to roughly 50% exposure at the beginning of December. I hope that some of you find this useful in implementing future strategies:
Ever since TSLA dipped below $140 I have been cashing out some of my solar gains and started buying a little bit of TSLA virtually every day over a three week period ending this Monday Dec. 2, just before the magnificent Tesla Tuesday. I made my first purchases on Tuesday, November 11 after Tesla dipped back into the $130s; I have been buying mostly Jan '16 options along with shares and June '14 options with some Jan '15 options.
Only a couple of my purchases from Nov. 11 are still slightly under water (even though I bought them in the $130's and now TSLA is above $140 = a lesson in volatility + time premium). But I made most of my purchases when TSLA was around $120 and actually was able to buy a Jun $155 option when TSLA was at the bottom around $116 for $9.50, now it is worth almost $18 for a quick double; you really have to be greedy when others are fearful. Most of my purchases have been Jan '16 options in the $210 - $260 range and as of right now I hold almost all of the 52-week lows in that range; I hope that for all our sake it stays that way till expiration.
Wealth of Knowledge on TMC
Even though Curt Renz was a little quick to call the bottom on Nov. 11 at $140 based on his gut feeling, he quickly redeemed himself on Nov. 18 at $120. This time he used his (extensive) knowledge on technical analysis and claimed that TSLA bottomed out based on the golden (Fibonacci) ratio of 0.618034. Based on this ratio TSLA would bottom out after a 38.2% decline which coincided with the $120 mark.
Then after a series of positive news (after which TSLA kept going down) culminated by the Deutsche Bank research note reiterating its $200 PT, the stock went up 6% to $127 on Wednesday Nov. 27 just before Thanksgiving. I thought that the good times were over and that my chances to accumulate TSLA on the cheap were over. At that time I had about 75% solar and 25% TSLA. I thought that DB called that bottom and posted it here on Thanksgiving day:
Short Term TSLA Investor Social Chat - Page 59
If you scroll down and flip to the next page, you will see that two prominent members here, DaveT and Norse, both agreed that this was the bottom; this was the confirmation that I needed to know that this is the (at least temporary) bottom. The next day, Friday, TSLA crossed the $130 mark in intraday trading, and I thought for sure that the good times of buying TSLA cheap are over, but then it slowed down a little before closing just slightly in the green.
The following Monday TSLA was showing weakness, so I quickly made my final wholesale purchases of TSLA; after all I was sure that we hit the bottom since my conviction was enforced by Curt's, DaveT's, and Norse's opinions. I was ecstatic that TSLA was trading at $124 on Monday. I took one of my wife's retirement accounts that was virtually 100% CSIQ and flipped it to 100% TSLA (still have a ton of CSIQ exposure, so no worries to CSIQ holders). I also bought some TSLA in my 401k and now it makes up a good chunk of that portfolio as well. My best purchase that day came towards the end of the trading day (usually the best time to buy options for those wondering - best time to sell is usually in the first 10 minutes of trading, but not always): I bought some June $160 options for $10.20. It was getting close to 4pm EST, and I checked the options price out of curiosity and I say bid/ask of $10.00/$10.20. I put in a limit order for full ask price as quick as I could, since I couldn't believe how cheap these options were (two days after DB called the bottom). The next day they were up about 70% and are still up 60% today.
For the newbie options traders: after TSLA first hit $120 options were going down in price, but did not get really cheap until 5-10 days due to consolidation, i.e. low volatility.
After TSLA went back to $140 the day after Germany cleared Tesla of any manufacturing defects (as well as bullish research notes from Morgan Stanley and Jeffries?), I quickly started selling some Jan '14 deep OTM options against my Jun '14 options as well as my J '15 options to raise cash to buy back some solar now that the sector has corrected about 20%; it still might go a little lower but I can't imagine anything more that 5%-10%. My goal is for those Jan '14's to expire worthless and then sell other calls in the future to continue raising cash.
What could have been
This past Tuesday (16% gain day closing price above $144) TSLA started out trading up "only" 6% in the low $130’s in the early minutes post market open. I knew that this will be the day of a huge TSLA run, because great stocks that are beaten down 40% tend to go up 20% on huge positive news days like this one. Even though I knew this, I once again failed to buy weekly OTM call options to take advantage of the situation. E.g. I could have bought the $145 weeklies for $0.15 in early trading and then sold them for a 20 bagger return by the end of the day.
I am very disappointed because even though I knew it will most likely be a huge day for TSLA I failed to make the correct options purchase decision. The problem is that it never crossed my mind to do so (failed once again) even though I mentally prepared myself for such an opportunity after missing the previous SCTY 22% move in a day. The day SCTY announced 2014 guidance I knew that the stock would go gangbusters, but it opened up only a few percentage points up (less than 10%). At the end of that trading day I realized that you could have bought the weekly $50’s for $0.05 early in the day and sold them for a 40 bagger return by the end of the day. I wasn’t upset with myself back then, because it wasn’t until the end of the trading day that I did some back testing and realized this opportunity. But I vowed not to miss a similar opportunity in the future, but I did with TSLA this past Tuesday. I am mad, because it completely skipped my mind and instead I made a different losing trade that morning with the cash I had. Just shows how hard trading really is; you may try to read, study, analyze, and learn everything there is on trading but all of that knowledge is useless if you fail to execute.
Summary
Even though I got a little bit off track with my post, what I really wanted to point out is that there are a lot of great people here on TMC and I wanted to thank everyone for their contributions. I also hope that a lot of people have bought a lot of TSLA in the $120’s (or lower) and that at least some people here on TMC realized that a lot of prominent posters all called the bottom at or near $120. I realized this and that is why I took advantage of the last great buying opportunity on Monday. Thanks again.
Potential downside
Even though I think that the sentiment has turned for TSLA to bullish there is still a real risk of more downside. The only two things I see dragging TSLA down would be:
- Big market correction, which is possible but all of the economic news looks very, very positive to me. The market has been shaky because it fears tapering. Tapering will not happen in Dec. Bernanke will leave that decision to Yellen, because it would not be fair to start the taper on his last day in office. He has to leave those cards available to the new FOMC Chair. In the end tapering will not matter; all that matters is economy and right now signs point that it is getting a lot better.
- Unforeseen big negative catalyst such as a mandatory recall, third debris fire, Goldman upgrade to $97 PT, etc.
Therefore, IMO there will not be any big market correction (more than 10%); and you cannot always fear that an unforeseen negative news story might unfold. In the end the odds favor the longs and TSLA has become a good stock once again. I still think we are stuck in the $135 - $155 range until we hear from NHTSA or other positive catalyst such as 2014 guidance, Model X reveal, etc. The good news is that such an announcement can also come any day: I think that the SCTY news today on battery storage is HUGE for TSLA and the market completely failed to price this in properly. Elon even tweeted:
Should mention that the battery cells used for this are 200 Wh/kg vs 250 for Model S. No short term supply constraint.
So it will not take away any batteries from the Model S. Another huge business opportunity (a lot bigger than making cars) and the market completely missed this one. The markets are not efficient one bit, this is where TSLA will make all of the easy money without huge capital expenditures (outside of giga battery factory which is needed for cars anyway). These storage devices are a huge deal, because they are higher margin than selling cars with a lot less headache and capital expenditures.
Elon confirms that Chinese Demand for Model S is Indeed Huge
I am disappointed that nobody on TMC talks about this (unless I missed a thread or discussion on this somewhere), but Elon basically confirmed on the CC that demand in China is huge, really huge.
Order now and wait 6 month or order 6 months from now and wait a lot longer.
That is not exactly what he said, but that is how I interpreted the message.
I didn’t have time to proof read, so I hope that this message is at least somewhat cohesive.
Happy investing everyone.