Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register

Electric Cars Are an “E-llusion”

This site may earn commission on affiliate links.

vfx

Well-Known Member
Aug 18, 2006
14,790
52
CA CA
http://www.hybridcars.com/incentives-laws/germany-der-spiegel-electric-cars-are-ellusion-27852.html

daimler-merkel-ed-400.jpg


the widely circulated German weekly Der Spiegel is calling the re-emergence of electric cars a “great e-llusion.” The magazine suggests that the attention given to “cars with power sockets rather than gas tanks” is more about publicity and political maneuvering than about a real shift to greener automotive technology.
 
The "Anti-Electric" arguments are more like "Anti-Electric myths".

There’s No Market: Without government subsidies, electric cars are virtually unmarketable. France offers customers an incentive of $6,500, China offers $8,500 and the United States offers $7,500. According to a study by Deutsche Bank, even with big government subsidies, only about 5 million electric cars could be registered in the European Union by 2020. That’s about 2 percent of the E.U. car parc.

Assuming Roadster-priced electric cars, yes they are unmarketable to the majority of people. However, a base Leaf costs $32,780 before any subsidies and the Model S price, with a projection of $57,400, means that government subsidies help but aren't necessary to sell cars. Once people realise the cost savings of electrics when gas hits $4-$5+/gallon, in addition to no need for oil changes and other maintenance costs of ICE vehicles subsidies won't be necessary to sell electrics.

Eco-Benefits are Marginal: According to Der Spiegel, Franz Fehrenbach, chief executive at Bosch—a major supplier of diesel equipment—contends that the environmental footprint of a mid-size diesel car is smaller than that of an electric car, when considering the carbon burned to produce the electricity. Yet, he and others believe that carmakers will find it difficult to achieve emissions targets planned in the EU for 2020 without electric cars.

This argument kind of nullifies itself and comes from a biased source. With an electric vehicle programmed to begin charging at night it won't effect the grid much, if at all. Electricity is also being produced more and more by renewable, non-polluting, means. If diesels are so "clean" then why in ten years would electrics be necessary to mean emissions standards?

Driving Range is Overstated: Consumers will be caught off-guard when range is less than advertised. An electric Smart supposedly has a range of 85 miles, but in a road test by German motoring magazine Auto Motor und Sport, the electric Smart only made it 65 miles on a single charge. Mitsubishi says that its i-MiEV will go 80 miles, but only yielded about 50 miles in testing.

This one I kind of agree with. I have yet to see any car, including an ICE, that yields sticker mileage in "real-world" driving conditions. But with batteries continuously getting better the range will only increase with time. In ten to fifteen years batteries will probably be able to go 500 miles or more on a charge. This would totally eliminate the need for consumer ICE vehicles.