What a textbook example of short-seller manipulation we had today. The day began with optimistic pre-market trading of TSLA around 194. The only reason people buy pre-market at more than $3 above closing is that they expect the SP to go even higher. Everything was set for a stellar climb: TSLA is historically at a bargain price, news is positive from TSLA over the past few weeks, TSLA climbed at the end of trading on Friday, Amateur hour of Monday is historically a time for new buyers to enter, and most importantly, the candidate who is most favored by the market and is also known to be particularly focused on climate change and clean energy, that presidential candidate went way up in expectations of winning over the weekend. As a result, the broader markets climbed more than 2% and clean energy stocks such as SCTY were up more than 3%. This should have been TSLA's day to climb. Yet
@vgrinshpun reported that at 8:45am there was a 347,000 share drawdown of available shares to short and on opening we saw not the vertical climb but instead saw more than 140,000 shares sold in the first 8 minutes, which dropped TSLA down so that it dipped its toe in the red-zone momentarily. TSLA resisted this dip and climbed back up, but when it hit 194 it plateaued for a few minutes before dropping. By 1:00pm, TSLA was climbing again, but when it hit about 193.30 it leveled off and stayed level. A brief dip allowed the horizontal trading to shift to 193. Towards close, a dip transitioned into a climb and TSLA climbed above 183 before quickly being pulled back down.
Normal trading for a volatile stock? Nope, not even close. There was no bad news on open, no valid reason for TSLA to plunge. If a big investor had wished to shed shares today, he would have allowed the share prices to zoom up in the morning and then slowly fed his shares to the hungry buyers throughout the day. The only reasonable explanation for the opening plunge was a big deployment of new short-selling aimed at curbing a runaway climb of TSLA today. The shorts were hanging tough, spending money to protect their current position. The horizontal trading of the afternoon is classic topping behavior by deep-pocket shorts. Want to see another example to horizontal trading that is topping behavior?
Check out the October 3 trading, right after Q3 delivery numbers were announced.
So, how do we as investors deal with this kind of short-selling behavior? First, here's the good news: TSLA has been manipulated in a skillful and heavy-handed way by deep-pocket shorts for months now. The morning dips, the topping behavior when critical price points are going to be reached, the selling in the late afternoon low-volume times, this is all classic short-seller manipulation. Short-selling will naturally depress the stock price, due to the additional selling that takes place as the number of short-sellers increases. The kind of methodical short-selling with a purpose we've seen, however, has considerably more ability to depress a stock price. In other words, TSLA is trading considerably lower right now then it would without this heavy-handed manipulation. What this tells me is when the shorts start to bail, it'll be one heck of a squeeze. The upward potential of TSLA is ferocious once the hold of the shorts can be shaken off.
The bad news is that we don't know exactly when the shorts can be shaken. Until that moment happens, it is mighty difficult to anticipate events such as this Monday, Q3 delivery numbers day, or the day following Q3 ER, which all should have been much more positive than they were. Please avoid the temptation to invest in the short-term, because quite frankly we're not playing a fair game at this time. Please do realize that TSLA is likely to succeed and the SP appreciation once the hold of the shorts is shaken could be tremendous.
Here's a short list of events that have some potential to shake loose the hold of the shorts:
* HRC wins the presidency AND the number of shares to short is minimal at Fidelity and other brokerages
* The TSLA/SCTY merger is approved and efforts to depress the stock are unsuccessful.
* Big institutions start adding to their TSLA holdings again as the share price starts to rise and the merger is completed
* Q4 Delivery numbers come out and Tesla lets the cat out of the bag early that the company will be GAAP profitable again, but this time without the help of ZEV credits
* Model 3 vehicles start rolling off the assembly line in substantial numbers.
Conditions:
* Dow up 371 (2.08%)
* NASDAQ up 119 {2.37%)
* TSLA 193.21, up 2.65 (1.39%)
* TSLA volume 3.9M shares
* SCTY 20.53, up 0.35 (3.21%)
* Oil 44.78, down 0.11 (0.25%)
* News: Over the weekend, HRC pulled a few points ahead and escaped FBI wrongdoing charges
- Tesla announced that unlimited free supercharger access will no longer be available in vehicles ordered after Jan 1, 2017 or not delivered by April 1, 2017.