We lost power today at around 7:20am. When the some came up around 830, the solar didn't come on. I have SolarEdge HD - it was displaying Error 18x7B, which is: MainError - Grid measurements are out of range. Contact the grid operator per SolarEdge manual. Also, I could tell the frequency was off as my UPS devices were showing grid outage and died.
When solar was still not on by 10am I called Tesla. The person said the battery was too cold to take a charge and would turn on the solar once it warmed up. I'm in Virginia -- it's cold here -- with the battery in my garage, the Tesla agent said it was showing a temp of 2.6 degrees celsius. She said the battery has a heater to warm itself up. 4 hours into the outage, the battery discharged to 55% and never brought the frequency in line to turn on the solar. At this point the power came back on.
When the power came back on, 5 minutes later the solar turned on (this was to be expected) and the battery immediately began taking a charge at over 4kW, peaking at 5kW until full a bit over an hour later. This seems to be a clear bug or at least a problem. If the battery was too cold to heat itself after 4 hours, that's a problem -- the heater is insufficient. However, this seems bogus because as soon as the grid returned, the battery began charging off the solar.
When I first got the system in June, I did some self tests by flipping the grid off. The system worked as expected during those tests -- the solar came on after 5 minutes (tripped off by the initial switch over) and charged the power till full at which point the solar turned off as the powerwall brought the frequency out of spec. I don't know what firmware that was, but it seemed to perform better. If the reason the battery wouldn't take a charge is because it was too cold, as Tesla says, that is unacceptable as it needs to be able to heat itself in a reasonable amount of time. And that doesn't explain why it charged itself as soon as the grid came online.
I will be following up with Tesla. I'm thrilled the powerwall kept my house running -- it was 10 degrees out when we lost power and we kept the lights on, the TV/internet running, and furnace going throughout the outage Neighbors came over as our schools were on a 2 hour delay and the kids watched movies here till it was time for school. However, I'm very concerned that the system didn't ever bring the solar online. If this outage has been more prolonged, we would have eventually run out of power despite the fact that it was a bright sunny day. Fortunately, our outages tend to be short. I'm curious if eventually, as the Powerwall got low enough, it would have switched on the solar eventually, but that would still be very flawed software as peak sun may have been gone by then.