However - if SP hadnt gone up as much as it did - but trades sideways - selling puts would have made way more than your calls.
Nope. IV increase was inevitable going into earnings. Sideways trading with rising volatility on a long call position would have
at least matched and most probably
beat a sold put position's profit...a position
that also would require significantly more capital.
Seriously, I'd encourage everyone to actually fact check their theories against hard numbers and self-evident market conditions instead of relying on speculation to drive their trading strategies.
Regarding "self evident market conditions", my entry point on that position was on
strong indication that price would go up.
--Earnings was in a month
--Volatility was at a low
--The symmetrical triangle was fixin' to break out
That's it. It's not rocket science, it's not a dark art.
Circling back on actual numbers, for the noted position I followed a pretty basic strategy of opening up a 6 month long call, a month out of earnings, with the intent of closing it before earnings (so, holding for one month). Taking numbers for today and applying them to that strategy, if we consider the following two positions today:
--A July $1000 long call (~$150 OTM) @$121, requires $12.1k capital.
--A July $700 short put (~$150 OTM) @$94, naked requires probably $50k capital, cash covered obviously requires ~$70k
Factoring in a 15 point jump in IV (which is pretty small and a little less than the rise over my position) and sideways trading (stock at $850) in one month (2/26) the contracts are worth:
--$1000 +C = $122.3k (or, $1275 profit)
--$700 -P = $94.3k (or, $300 loss)
I don't know about anyone else, but I prefer profit to loss.
Why would you want any stress in your life when you make >$30k a month?
...because, with
less stress buying occasional strong long positions, you can retire early and then have
zero stress?