Do we really think trading will supersede reasonable valuations in this environment? Tesla would be expensive over $1500 and I’m not sure I’m still willing to pay more then 50x forward earnings anymore. I still believe in the story but I’m not an aggressive buyer unless we have a clear bull market in sight. This is coming from someone still sitting in a few LEAPs and who has 60% of their money in TSLA.
This is the wild card - company or market/macro - what will dominate? My own odds are something like 2/3rds macro / inflation / QT / war will dominate over August and September (until we get close to Q3 production report), and 1/3rd that the details on the 3:1 split will be announced and will become the dominant driver of the share price.
I just see a really big jump up possible on that 1/3rd chance, but a reasonably normal / small move down on that 2/3rds.
To your question - just what is a reasonable valuation for a company that is growing unit volumes >50% year over year, has been doing that for years, and is guiding to continue doing that for years to come?
Is doing so by fully funding capital and research from cash flow, and is showing significant free cash flow on top of that. ALSO while having a higher and higher % of that incremental revenue falling through to the bottom line. The combination is unprecedented - to find something somewhat comparable you start looking at much smaller companies where 50x is trivially small.
The closest big company analog that I know of is Amazon, and even there, 20% year over year at such stupendous size was unprecedented.
Maybe your level really is a reasonable valuation - I don't know. I know that this stock split is a catalyst that -could- cause the entire market to reset their valuation of the company. Maybe the market finally notices that, if anything, Tesla is position to grow even faster than ridiculously fast for the next year or 2, and to put some value on that.
It's that reset that I've seen. 2 or 3 times in Tesla's history, that might be about to happen again, that I'm trying to figure out how I want to be positioned.