I get the feeling you’re awfully sensitive when people don’t agree with you.
1. This is a fan club.
2. This is also the investor thread of said fan club where for years we have discussed in minute detail all aspects of Tesla. It’s why many of us are now monetarily well off. Clearly the investment thread has worked despite your attempt at belittling it and its participants.
3. Don’t be the ‘hindsight’ guy who neglects to remember the situations and circumstances surrounding decisions made years ago.
4. Nobody has ever said mistakes haven’t been made, but saying that something might have been a screw up after the fact doesn’t make you some investment prophet nor add to investment decisions going forward, especially when you’ve just done #3 and entirely mislabeled a decision.
5. Consider for a moment you’ve only been here for 3 years and perhaps might not possess the information of the years prior to your joining - ironically the years in which Tesla was making decisions about Gigafactory #1.
6. I’ve been all in Tesla/TSLA since 2012. I’m aware of absolutely everything of public record and while GigaNevada hasn’t turned out the way Tesla initially envisioned it, it wasn’t a screw up.
7. Mistakes and fails are not ‘negatives’ to Tesla/any Elon company. ‘Fail as fast as you can’ is in fact a very good strategy in this case.
GigaNevada has been instrumental in Tesla’s success. It’s a testing ground and its existence has helped model future factories; locations, layouts, efficiencies, increased vertical integration. partnerships, etc…
It’s been a huge success regardless of not reaching its original intended ‘dream’.
I wish there were a stronger statement than just 'Love' or 'Informative' for this post.
There are common themes among those of us who have been investors in Elon enterprises since 2010 or before:
-we often disagree with each other but almost always explain why,
-we often find fault with some aspects of Tesla and executives, including Elon Musk,
-we express irritation and anguish over recurrent customer treatment (on innumerable issues)',
-we all know that our investments in Tesla have been either the most successful one of the most successful investments we've ever made,
- of course, we love our Tesla products almost without exception.
For me personally, the majority of my 'disagrees' come from this camp. For that matter, perhaps more of the positive ones too.
That is in large part why I pay close attention to such people. They know this company, its products, its finances, its strengths and its weaknesses.
Nearly all of us sound like 'fans' because we are. That does not make us unobservant of error. On the contrary, such people tend to see the warts also.